The Worst Practices for Gift Recipients

Retailers With Difficult Gift Exchange and Worst Return Policies

How a retailer handles a merchandise sale is no less important than how the retailer handles the return of that same merchandise. Customer unfriendly policies which make a gift return difficult or impossible can cause a retailer to lose two customers if both the gift recipient is inconvenienced, and the gift giver is embarrassed.

Retailers wanting to make enemies and lose customers in their own operation can adopt some or all of these return worst practices. Retailers that understand the customer acquisition value of customer-centric gift return policies will avoid these gift return practices employed by someĀ major US retailers.

    Target, Gift Return Worst Policies

    target gift return worst practices
    gremlin/Vetta/Getty Images

    Some items purchased at cannot be returned to a Target store. But gift givers won't know for sure which items are store returnable and which items are not until after the purchase is made.

    Target and also will not accept returns for items without a receipt or gift receipt. You'll get no store credit, no exchanges, and no exceptions with this gifter unfriendly return policy.

    Target doesn't do exchanges either. You have to return an item, get a refund, and then repurchase the replacement you want. Besides the hassle and time involved with this non-exchange policy, customers who conduct all transactions by mail will have the added bonus of paying all the shipping charges both ways with this redundant process.

    BJs Wholesale Club, Gift Return Worst Policies

    Getty Images

    This east coast membership discount club has not yet fully embraced multi-channel integration, and will not allow customers to return e-commerce purchases to any of its 175 stores. While this is inconvenient for the BJ's member buyer, it is impossible for the receiver of a BJ's gift. To return an item, a gift receiver must obtain a return authorization number, but only the purchasing BJ's member can obtain this number. There is no such thing as a discreet return of a gift.

    Beware of purchasing a large screen TV from BJ' too. When you sign for it, you declare that it's in good working order. How do you know that if it's still in its delivery box? Don't try to ask BJ's. They'll make you take it up with the manufacturer.

    Barnes & Noble, Gift Return Worst Policies

    Barnes & Noble Gift Return Worst Practices
    Getty Images

    You can return gifts purchased from a Barnes and Noble store or from their e-commerce site to any of their retail stores, but you have to do it within 14 days. Chances are, before it was wrapped, the time to return a Barnes & Noble gift had probably already expired.

    The worst Barnes & Noble return policy, though, is their "you pay for it, we keep it" policy. If you return merchandise through the mail and it misses the 14-day return deadline, or you forget to include the packing slip, Barnes and Noble says, "We regret that we cannot issue a refund or send the merchandise back to you."

    What happens to this unreturned, unrefunded merchandise? It's logical to assume that it will be regifted after it is repurchased by someone else.

    Best Buy, Gift Return Worst Policies

    Best Buy Gift Return Worst Practices
    Reprinted with permission from

    Those who purchase a computer from Best Buy or should make it a last-minute purchase. Opened or not, receipt or not, in-store or by mail, Best Buy will not accept computer returns after 14 days. Surprisingly this is not the worst part of Best Buy's return merchandise policy.

    If you make a purchase for $250 or more with cash or debit card, you will not receive a cash or debit card refund if you return the purchase. Rather, Best Buy will issue your refund by check within 10 business days. From a customer's point of view, it seems logical that a store that has the ability to take cash and debit cards should also have the ability to give it back. Cash customers may choose to shop someplace where cash is less difficult.

    1 Gift Return Worst Policies gift return worst practices
    Getty Images wins the award for having the best of the worst gift return policies. In short,'s policy is "Go ahead and return it. We dare you."

    There are eight steps for requesting a return merchandise authorization (RMA) number. After that, there's another detailed set of instructions for the return. Failure to follow each step and rule results in the return being rejected, and the item shipped back to you at your expense. With this rejection, you also forfeit your right to receive a refund or exchange on that item at any time in the future. claims, "Our arrangements with our suppliers and manufacturers allow us no room to make exceptions."

    Shouldn't customers factor into all retailing "arrangements?"