Will the US Debt Ever Be Paid Off?
An Overlooked Way to Reduce the U.S. Debt While Boosting Growth
The debt grew despite Congressional threats to not raise the debt ceiling. In 2011, the U.S. debt crisis almost forced America to default on its debt. In 2012, the fiscal cliff crisis almost stopped the government in its tracks. In 2013, the government shut down for 15 days. Since these attempts didn't work, what can and should be done?
Four Ways the United States Can Pay Off Its Debt
There are four ways to decrease the debt.
The first is to cut spending. Sequestration tried to force the government to cut discretionary spending by 10%. No one in Congress thought it was a good idea. Members adopted it to force themselves to come up with something better. The Simpson-Bowles report recommended many good ways to cut the debt. But Congress ignored it. Even with sequestration, the debt continued to grow. To truly cut the debt, Congress would have to cut spending so severely that it would slow economic growth. Government spending is a component of gross domestic product.
The second is to raise taxes. That could also slow growth. That's especially true if the tax rate is more than 50%, according to the Laffer Curve. If Congress raises the tax rate beyond that level, then the additional revenue generated will be lower than before. That tax rate is enough to curb incentives to grow businesses and income.
Grow the Economy Faster Than the Debt
The third is to drive economic growth at a faster rate than the debt. This means decreasing the debt-to-GDP ratio by increasing GDP. But Congress disagrees on how to grow the economy. Most Democrats say increased spending works the best. Most Republicans say lower taxes will boost growth the most. Both tactics will definitely increase the debt, possibly more than GDP.
There is a fourth solution that's rarely discussed. Congress should shift spending to areas that create the most jobs.
Research shows that spending on bridges, roads, and public buildings creates the most jobs per buck.
The next best is education spending. Almost 15% of government spending goes to the military. Contrary to popular opinion, that's not the economy-booster it was in World War II. One reason that it spends more on technology and equipment than in the 1940s. To reduce the debt, the government should shift spending from defense to public infrastructure and education. This is one of the four best real-world ways to create jobs.
Why the United States Hasn't Gotten Out of Debt
It's unlikely America will ever pay off its national debt. It doesn’t need to while creditors remain confident they will be repaid.
Most creditors don’t worry until the sovereign debt is more than 77% of GDP, according to the World Bank. In the first quarter of 2020, the U.S. debt-to-GDP ratio was 110%. That's the $23.7 trillion U.S. debt as of March 31, 2020, divided by the $21.5 trillion nominal GDP.
Around $17.7 trillion of this debt is public debt. That's what the government owes to investors. Another $6 trillion is debt the government owes to itself. That’s mostly the Social Security Trust Fund. The government will need to pay this one day, as Baby Boomers retire. Creditors aren't worried about this component of the debt yet.
Since the debt has gone beyond the tipping point, why won't the U.S. government do more to reduce the debt? There are three reasons why that probably won’t happen.
First, the U.S. economy has historically outpaced its debt. For example, the U.S. debt at the end of World War II was $260 billion. That was 14% more than GDP. But the economy grew beyond that in just three years. By 1960, it was double. Congress believes that today's debt will be dwarfed by tomorrow's economic growth.
Second, Congress has a lot to lose by cutting spending. For example, if elected officials cut Social Security or Medicare benefits, they will lose their next election.
Third, that can also happen if they raise taxes. A tax increase cost President George H.W. Bush his second term. Voters remembered he had said, “Read my lips. No new taxes.” He did raise taxes in 1990 to cut $500 billion from the deficit over the following five years. You will notice most elected officials only want to raise taxes or cut spending on their opponents’ constituents.
Most people assume the only way the United States will reduce its debt is if the American people are ready to tighten their belts and accept austerity measures.
The most painless time to reduce the debt is when the economy is expanding. That’s when GDP growth rates are greater than 3% and unemployment is less than 5%. In fact, that's the BEST time to cut the debt. It will prevent a boom and subsequent bust.
Booms and busts result from business cycle stages. These are the four phases a nation’s economy goes through. Economic expansion is part of this cycle. Its emergence and those of the other phases in the business cycle are dependent on many factors. Such factors include the effects of monetary and fiscal policies.
U.S. Debt Milestones
Here are some debt milestones since 1929. The U.S. debt exceeded $25 trillion in May 2020. Congress has suspended the debt limit until after the 2020 presidential election. It wants to avoid a repeat of the 2011 and 2013 debt crises that hampered Congress during an election year.
|The Debt Exceeded||On This Date *|
|$5 trillion||Feb. 23, 1996|
|$6 trillion||Feb. 26, 2002|
|$7 trillion||Jan. 15, 2004|
|$8 trillion||Oct. 18, 2005|
|$9 trillion||Sept. 5, 2007|
|$10 trillion||Sept. 30, 2008|
|$11 trillion||March 16, 2009|
|$12 trillion||Nov. 16, 2009|
|$13 trillion||June 1, 2010|
|$14 trillion||Dec. 31, 2010|
|$15 trillion||Nov. 15, 2011|
|$16 trillion||Aug. 31, 2012|
|$17 trillion||Oct. 17, 2013|
|$18 trillion||Dec. 15, 2014|
|$19 trillion||Jan. 29, 2016|
|$20 trillion||Sept. 8, 2017|
|$21 trillion||March 15, 2018|
|$22 trillion||Feb. 11, 2019|
|$23 trillion||Oct. 31, 2020|
|$24 trillion||April 7, 2020|
|$25 trillion||May 4, 2020|
|$26 trillion||June 10, 2020|
*Note: Before 1996, debt levels are not available for each day. (Source: “U.S. Debt to the Penny,” United States Department of the Treasury.) Data on the U.S. debt by president shows how much each president contributed to the national debt.
The Bottom Line
The U.S. debt is the highest in the world. Debt owed to the Social Security Trust Fund comprises the bulk of this obligation. To pay its dues, the United States has these options:
- Cut government spending, although this could slow economic growth.
- Raise taxes.
- Increase national income by driving up GDP beyond the debt level. Democrats champion government spending, while Republicans advocate tax cuts to achieve this goal.
- Appropriate government spending on sectors that significantly raise employment such as education and infrastructure.
Despite a looming obligation, creditors remain confident of America’s ability to pay.
U.S. Department of the Treasury. "Debt to the Penny." Accessed July 2, 2020.
TreasuryDirect.gov. "Debt to the Penny (Daily History Search)." Accessed June 1, 2020.
Congressional Research Service. "The FY2014 Government Shutdown: Economic Effects." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
Congressional Research Service. "The Debt Limit Since 2011." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
House Committee on the Budget. "Summary of the Budget Control Act of 2011." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
Congressman Kurt Schrader. "Highlights of 'Simpson-Bowles' Budget Alternative." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
University of Mississippi. "Tax Revenue Versus Tax Rates: A Discussion of the Laffer Curve." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. "Could Faster Growth Solve Our Debt Woes?" Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
Political Economy Research Institute at University of Massachusetts Amherst. "The U.S. Employment Effects of Military and Domestic Spending Priorities: 2011 Update." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
Peter G. Peterson Foundation. "Budget Basics: National Defense." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
World Bank Group eLibrary. "Finding the Tipping Point — When Sovereign Debt Turns Bad." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
Bureau of Economic Analysis. "National Data: National Income and Product Accounts: Table 1.1.5 Gross Domestic Product." Accessed June 1, 2020.
TreasuryDirect.gov. "The Debt to the Penny and Who Holds It." Accessed June 1, 2020.
Pew Research Center. "5 Facts About the National Debt." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
U.S. Department of Treasury. "National Debt." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
TreasuryDirect.gov. "Historical Debt Outstanding - Annual 1900 - 1949." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. "Gross Domestic Product." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.
Congress.gov. "H.R.5835 - Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990." Accessed Feb. 25, 2020.