Window dressing occurs when a company or financial institution makes cosmetic changes, often at the end of a reporting period, to improve investors’ perceptions of its financial condition.
Investors can face window dressing in any security they invest in, but they’re most likely to come across it when investing in mutual funds or stock of some companies. Learn more about how mutual funds and public companies can use window dressing and discuss ways you can spot it in securities you own or are considering investing in.
Definition and Example of Window Dressing in Finance
Window dressing is a term used to describe cosmetic changes a financial institution might make, often near the end of a reporting period, to improve its appearance to investors. The term is inspired by an entirely different sector: consumer retail.
In retail, window dressing refers to decorating the outside of a store to entice shoppers to come in. It often involves seasonal decor, mannequins, and strategic lighting. The goal of window dressing is to catch the attention of potential customers and draw them in.
Window Dressing in Mutual Funds
With mutual funds, window dressing refers to the superficial changes a fund might make to its portfolio of holdings to appear more attractive to current and prospective investors. At a glance, a potential investor might be drawn in with what appears to be good performance.
For example, a mutual fund management team might choose to sell losing stocks and buy winning ones at or around the end of a quarter. This strategy hides weak performance and gives investors a perception of impressive returns.
Window Dressing in Stocks
In an example from another part of the world of finance, public companies sometimes use window dressing when reporting earnings. Depending on the specifics, this practice can range from “creative accounting” to something bordering on or actually qualifying as fraud. For example, some economics researchers cite rounding as a manipulative form of window dressing. A firm might round $5.99 million in quarterly earnings up to $6 million because the round number can be more psychologically attractive.
How Window Dressing in Finance Works
In relation to mutual funds, window dressing is defined by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as “buying or selling portfolio securities shortly before the date as of which a fund's holdings are publicly disclosed, in order to convey an impression that the manager has been investing in companies that have had exceptional performance during the reporting period.”
Responding to a wide array of concerns over window dressing, the SEC issued a rule in 2004 that requires mutual fund companies to report their portfolio holdings at the end of each quarter. This requirement gives investors deeper and more frequent looks at mutual fund holdings, allowing them to more fully understand the performance of their investments.
However, window dressing may still occur. For example, funds will sometimes sell a stock that performed poorly over the holiday season so it doesn’t show up in their fourth-quarter report, only to buy it back in the first quarter of the following year. This form of window dressing hurts investment returns due to excessive trading costs.
What Window Dressing in Finance Means for Individual Investors
The SEC reporting requirements can help investors better assess the management and performance of mutual funds. By requiring funds to report their portfolio holdings quarterly rather than semi-annually, the SEC effectively gave investors the opportunity to take a better look under the hood of a mutual fund.
For example, you can parse out the stocks a fund has held consistently over time versus winners added as window dressing at the end of a weak quarter. If the fund’s holdings and performance check out upon closer inspection, you might be more inclined to remain or become an investor.
The risk of window dressing simply means individual investors need to do their homework, and the SEC’s requirements make it easier to do so. Before investing, individuals should examine a fund’s holdings and when and for how long managers held particular stocks.
- Window dressing refers to cosmetic improvements intended to improve a fund or financial institution’s appearance to investors.
- Window dressing can happen across finance, ranging from deceptive accounting practices to last-minute portfolio adjustments.
- In mutual funds, window dressing generally refers to the practice of selling losers and buying winners at the end of the quarter to make superficial changes to a fund’s slate of holdings, thereby improving investor perception of the fund’s performance.
- In 2004, the SEC attempted to address window dressing by requiring mutual funds to report their holdings every quarter, rather than semi-annually.