QE1 and How It Stopped the 2008 Recession
The Quick Thinking That Saved the Housing Market
QE1 is the nickname given to the Federal Reserve's initial round of quantitative easing. That's when the Fed massively increased its standard open market operations. It purchased the debt from its member banks. The debt was mortgage-backed securities, consumer loans, or Treasury bills, bonds, and notes. The Fed bought them through its trading desk at the New York Federal Reserve Bank.
The Fed can buy as much debt as it wants, anytime it wants. Like all other central banks, it has the authority to create credit out of thin air. It has this ability so it can quickly pump liquidity into the economy as needed.
The QE1 program purchases lasted from December 2008 until March 2010. There were additional transactions made from April through August 2010 to facilitate the settlement of the initial purchases.
The Fed announced QE1 on November 25, 2008. Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke announced an aggressive attack on the financial crisis of 2008. The Fed began buying $500 billion in mortgage-backed securities and $100 billion in other debt. QE supported the housing market that the subprime mortgage crisis had devastated.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac guaranteed the securities. They are two agencies established by the government to boost the housing market. Historically, Fannie Mae has bought mortgages from large retail banks while Freddie Mac bought them from smaller thrift ones.
In December 2008, the Fed cut the fed funds rate to near zero and the discount rate to 0.5%. The Fed even began paying interest to banks for their reserve requirements. At that point, all of the Fed's most important expansionary monetary policy tools had reached their limits. As a result, quantitative easing became the central bank's primary tool to stop the crisis.
By March 2009, the Fed's portfolio of securities had reached a record $1.75 trillion. The central bank continued to expand QE1 to fight the worsening recession. That month, it announced it would buy $750 billion more in mortgage-backed securities, $100 billion in Fannie and Freddie debt, and $300 billion of longer-term Treasurys over the next six months.
By June 2010, the Fed's portfolio had expanded to an alarming $2.1 trillion. Bernanke halted further purchases since the economy had improved.
Despite QE1, Banks Weren't Lending
But by August, Bernanke hinted that the Fed might resume QE because the economy was still lackluster. Banks still weren't lending as much as the Fed had hoped. Instead, they were hoarding the cash. They were using it to write down the rest of the subprime mortgage debt they still had on their books. Others were increasing their capital ratios, just in case.
Many banks complained that there just weren't enough credit-worthy borrowers. Perhaps that was because banks had also raised their lending standards. For whatever reason, the Fed's QE1 program looked a lot like pushing a string. The Fed couldn't force banks to lend, so it just kept giving them incentives to do so.
Fed pumped liquidity into banks.
Fed can “create money” which allowed banks to weather the subprime mortgage crisis.
QE1 significantly lowered interest rates.
Low rates kept the housing market afloat.
QE1’s added liquidity wasn't enough to compel banks to increase their loans.
Money supply did not increase substantially.
Consumer demand did not increase enough to boost the economy.
Investors were worried about QE's potential for inflation.
Despite Three Drawbacks, QE1 Worked
QE1 had some significant drawbacks, but it did work overall. The first problem, as mentioned, was that it was not effective in forcing banks to lend. If the $1 trillion or so that the Fed had pumped into banks had been loaned out, it would have boosted the economy by $10 trillion. Unfortunately, the Fed didn't have the authority to make the banks lend it, and so it didn't work as anticipated.
Before the COVID-19 pandemic, a big bank only had to keep 10% of its total assets in reserve. That's known as the reserve requirement. It could lend the rest, which then gets deposited in other banks. That's how $1 trillion in Fed credit could have became $10 trillion in economic growth during the Great Recession.
QE1 led to the second problem. The Fed now had a record-high level of potentially dangerous assets on its balance sheet. Some experts became concerned that the Fed had absorbed the subprime mortgage crisis. They worried that the massive amount of toxic loans might cripple it like they did the banks.
But the Fed has an unlimited ability to create cash to cover any toxic debt. It was able to sit on the debt until the housing market had recovered. At that point, those "bad" loans became good. They had enough collateral to support them.
That, of course, led to the third problem with quantitative easing. At some point, it could create inflation or even hyperinflation. The more dollars the Fed creates, the less valuable existing dollars are. Over time, this lowers the value of all dollars, which then buys less. The result is inflation.
But the Fed was trying to create mild inflation. That's because it was counteracting deflation in housing, where prices had plummeted 30% from their peak in 2006. The Fed was dealing with the immediate crisis. It wasn't worried about inflation. Why? Because inflation doesn't occur until the economy is thriving. That's a problem the Fed would welcome. At that time, the assets on the Fed's books would have increased in value as well. The Fed would have no problem selling them. Selling assets would also reduce the money supply and cool off any inflation.
That's why QE1 was a success. It lowered interest rates almost a full percentage point. Rates fell from 5.21% in April 2010 to November 2011 to 3.98% in November 2011 for a 30-year fixed interest mortgage.
These low rates kept the housing market on life support. They also pushed investors into alternatives. Unfortunately, sometimes this included runs on oil and gold, shooting prices sky-high. But, record-low interest rates provided the lubrication needed to get the American economic engine cranking again.
Federal Reserve. "Employment Effects of Unconventional Monetary Policy: Evidence from QE," Page 10. Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Congressional Research Service. "Quantitative Easing and the Growth in the Federal Reserve’s Balance Sheet," Page 3. Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. "Federal Reserve Announces it Will Initiate a Program to Purchase the Direct Obligations of Housing-Related Government-Sponsored Enterprises and Mortgage-Backed Securities Backed by Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and Ginnie Mae." Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Federal Housing Finance Agency. "Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac." Accessed Nov. 27, 2020.
Federal Reserve Bank of New York. "The Rescue of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac," Pages 6-7. Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. "FOMC Statement." Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. "Why Did the Federal Reserve Start Paying Interest on Reserve Balances Held on Deposit at the Fed? Does the Fed Pay Interest on Required Reserves, Excess Reserves, or Both? What Interest Rate Does the Fed Pay?" Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Federal Reserve Bank of New York. "Large-Scale Asset Purchases." Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Kentucky Public Service Commission. "What Is Quantitative Easing?" Page 1. Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. "The Economic Outlook and Monetary Policy." Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. "Reserve Requirements." Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Federal Reserve History. "The Great Recession." Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. "30-Year Fixed Rate Mortgage Average in the United States." Accessed Nov. 30, 2020.