What Is Protectionism?
Its Impact on Global Investments
Protectionism is what a country does to protect its domestic manufacturing from foreign competition. The most common form it takes is tariffs placed on foreign imported goods, which typically means higher prices for the consumer.
Protectionism has a broad definition that encompasses a number of different economic policies designed to restrict trade and boost domestic manufacturing. From new taxes to import restrictions, these policies are implemented by both emerging markets and developed economies and can have a negative impact on global free trade.
For instance, the United States, believing that China is undervaluing its currency to make exports cheaper, imposed a tariff on certain goods imported from the country. President Trump initiated a restricted set of tariffs in 2018 and has since expanded the scope to encompass anything China exports—including clothing—effective September 2019.
In other cases, a government may only seek to protect a single strategic industry. In 2012, many countries imposed tariffs on Chinese photovoltaic solar panels after the country began dumping them into the global market to handle an oversupply due to a slowdown in demand. The goal was to protect their own domestic solar operations and ensure energy security in the future.
Most of the time, protectionism stems from a desire to strengthen the domestic manufacturing industry by making it more competitive with imported goods. And oftentimes, these desires result from a weak job market that could be improved with more domestic manufacturing jobs.
In other cases, developing countries restrict imports to give their domestic businesses the time to acquire enough expertise to manufacture products of a quality that allows them to compete globally.
Types of Protectionism
Some of the most popular protectionist policies include:
- Import tariffs: Taxing imported goods increases the cost to importers and raises the price of the imported goods in local markets.
- Import quotas: Limiting the number of goods that can be produced abroad and sold domestically limits foreign competition in domestic markets.
- Domestic subsidies: Subsidizing costs or providing cheap loans to domestic companies can increase their competitiveness against foreign imports.
- Exchange rates: Intervening in the foreign exchange (Forex) market to lower a currency's valuation can raise the cost of imports and lower the cost of exports.
- Administrative barriers: Excessive government regulations can place huge burdens on foreign imports, making it difficult to sell them in domestic markets.
Costs of Protectionism
There's little question among economists that protectionism is harmful, with costs that far outweigh benefits over the long term. Comparative advantage provides much of the rationale for this argument, saying that two countries can benefit from free trade, even if one is more efficient in the production of all goods than the other.
Comparative advantage has its roots in the 18th century and was conceived by economist David Ricardo. He maintained that it is best for a country to focus on what it can produce most efficiently and trade with countries that lack its capabilities in other areas. For instance, England had an advantage creating products requiring machinery while other countries were more suited to produce wheat because of their climate and land. So rather than impose tariffs on imported wheat, which would hurt the British consumer, Ricardo convinced England to allow for open trade.
Arguments for Protectionism
Despite the beliefs held by many mainstream economists, there are others who argue for protectionism. These economists insist that the mobility of capital around the world undercuts comparative advantage, as capital can move to wherever costs are lowest to pursue an absolute advantage, thereby eliminating the key premise.
Proponents for protectionism further argue that nearly all developed countries have successfully implemented protectionist programs. Yet it's difficult to determine cause and effect when looking at why a certain industry has succeeded. The reason may be despite protectionism and due to higher quality or better marketing.