President Herbert Hoover's Economic Policies

President Herbert Hoover and his wife, Lou Henry Hoover, in Chicago at the final game of the 1929 World Series.
•••

Photo by Chicago History Museum / Getty Images

Herbert Clark Hoover was the 31st U.S. president, serving from 1929 to 1933. He rode into power because of his success during World War I and the Roaring Twenties. The recession that started the Great Depression began in August 1929. The stock market crashed in October. The rest of his presidency was consumed with the Great Depression.

Hoover was an advocate of laissez-faire economics. He believed an economy based on capitalism would self-correct. He felt that economic assistance would make people stop working. He believed business prosperity would trickle down to the average person. This philosophy was not effective against the Depression. His failure to end it led to his defeat in the 1932 presidential election against Franklin D. Roosevelt and his New Deal.

As a result, Hoover's enduring legacy is tainted by economic near-collapse. Many of his achievements have gone unnoticed. For example, in 1931, he signed a law that made "The Star-Spangled Banner" America's national anthem. A self-made millionaire, he donated his presidential salary to charity. He also saved millions from starvation during the two world wars.

Key Takeaways

  • Herbert Hoover presided as president of the United States during the beginning of the Great Depression.
  • He tried to end the Great Depression by using a "laissez faire" approach, but it did not do much to help the economy.
  • While Herbert Hoover is often blamed for the Great Depression, many of the reasons the economy collapsed were there before he was elected.

What Did Hoover Do To End the Depression?

Hoover tried many tactics to fight the Depression. He encouraged business leaders to keep workers. He gave many public speeches to instill confidence and prevent panic. Hoover did not believe the federal government should fix prices, control businesses, or manipulate the value of the currency. He thought these would lead to socialism.

  • In 1929, Hoover cut taxes. He lowered the top rate from 25% to 24%.
  • In December 1930, he raised it back to 25%.
  • In 1930, Hoover vetoed several bills that would have provided direct relief to struggling Americans. “Prosperity cannot be restored by raids upon the public Treasury,” he explained in his 1930 address to Congress. Instead, he protected businesses by signing the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act. It was supposed to protect farmers but ended up imposing 40% tariffs on 900 products. That year, the nation's gross domestic product fell 8.5%. The unemployment rate was 8.7%.
  • In 1931, other countries retaliated with their own tariffs. The resultant trade war reduced international trade by 67%. GDP growth fell 6.4% while the unemployment rate rose to 15.9%.
  • In 1932, the economy shrank 12.9%. But Hoover raised the top rate to 63% to reduce the deficit. His commitment to a balanced budget worsened the Depression.
  • In 1932, Hoover approved the Reconstruction Finance Corporation to prevent more bankruptcies.
  • By 1933, it disbursed $2 billion to failing banks, railroads, and a few other businesses. It was effective in keeping them from going under. In July, the Emergency Relief Act empowered the RFC to lend money to states to feed the unemployed and expand public works. Hoover felt that the states should provide for the unemployed. He was opposed to too much federal intervention.
  • Hoover signed the Revenue Act of 1932. It increased the top income tax rate to 63%. He wanted to reduce the federal deficit. Hoover believed it would also restore confidence. Instead, higher taxes worsened the Depression. GDP growth fell 12.9% and unemployment was 23.6%.

Did Hoover Cause the Depression?

The causes of the Great Depression were already in place before Hoover took office. The stock market was volatile. Its value had risen 20% a year since 1924. The number of shares traded doubled to 5 million per day. People were buying stocks "on margin." They only needed to put down 10%-20% and their brokers would lend the rest. When prices rose, they became millionaires. But they become instant paupers when the market crashed.

The Federal Reserve used a contractionary monetary policy to defend the gold standard. Instead, it should have lowered interest rates to fight the recession. In August 1929, the Fed raised the discount rate from 5% to 6%. That made loans more expensive right when banks needed cheap funds.

The banking system was unstable. Only one-third of the nation's 24,000 banks belonged to the Federal Reserve banking system. Non-members relied on one another to hold reserves. They were vulnerable to bank runs, which is when depositors rush to withdraw their savings. Banks only hold 10% of all deposits, so they can lend out the rest.

Banks held fictitious reserves. Checks were double-counted by the sending bank and the receiving bank, which counted them before they had cleared.

In 1930, the Bank of Tennessee failed. That led to the failures of affiliate banks in the next few days. By the end of the year, 1,300 banks had failed. As banks failed, it reduced the money supply because there was less credit available. That meant each dollar was worth more. As the value of the dollar rose, prices fell. That reduced revenue for businesses. Higher interest rates meant that debt cost more for lenders to pay back. That created a ripple effect of personal and business bankruptcies.

Hoover could do little to stop the Dust Bowl drought, another major cause of the Depression. It was a 10-year drought that affected 23 states, from the Mississippi River to the mid-Atlantic region. It was the worst drought in 300 years. As crops failed, farmers could not produce enough to eat. Hoover asked the Red Cross to help. It supplied $5 million for seeds. As the crisis worsened, Congress appropriated $45 million for seed and $20 million for food boxes, but the drought was so bad that it didn't really help. The only crop that would grow was turnips.

Hoover should have lowered taxes more than he did. He definitely shouldn't have raised them. His concern for balancing the budget, though commendable, was ill-timed. He shouldn't have imposed trade-destroying tariffs, but his response did not cause the Great Depression.

Why Hoover Was Blamed

People wrongly blame Hoover for the Depression because it occurred after he took office. In 1930, unemployment rose, the Dust Bowl destroyed farms in the Midwest, and people lost their homes. Many traveled to California, where they thought they could find work. Instead, they lived in their cars or in shantytowns that became known as Hoovervilles.

People attached Hoover's name to many of the signs of the newly destitute. "Hoover blankets” were the newspapers used to cover the homeless in the winter. “Hoover flags” were empty pants pockets pulled inside-out to show the lack of money. “Hoover leather” was the cardboard that replaced worn-out soles of shoes. “Hoover wagons” were the cars pulled by horses because gas was too expensive.

In 1932, thousands of World War I veterans set up a Hooverville in Washington, D.C. They asked for early payments of promised government bonuses. The government refused, claiming budget restrictions. When the veterans refused to leave, Hoover sent in the Army. Troops set fire to the Hooverville and drove the group from the city with bayonets and tear gas. This further turned the population against Hoover.

Hoover and the Debt

The Depression destroyed Hoover's hopes of balancing the budget. Hoover added a $1 billion surplus in 1930, but that didn't last. By the end of his term, he added $6 billion to the debt, a 33% increase.

Hoover's Early Years

Hoover was born in Iowa in 1874. He was the first president born west of the Mississippi. He was orphaned by the time he was 9. He was separated from his siblings and sent to live with an uncle in Oregon. He received an engineering degree from Stanford University's inaugural class. He was so poor he lived in the construction workers' barracks.

Hoover's poverty gave him the drive to succeed. As a mining engineer, he traveled the world to locate mineral deposits. He started his own company and soon had businesses throughout the world.

His early adversities also made him a kindhearted man. While working in China in his first job, he risked his life rescuing Chinese children during the Boxer Rebellion. He helped get stranded tourists home during the outbreak of World War I and helped feed 9 million Belgians. This gave him the deserved reputation of a humanitarian.

During World War I, President Woodrow Wilson made Hoover the head of the Food Security Administration. Hoover fed the troops without resorting to rationing at home. After the war, he headed the American Relief Administration, where he fed 15 million famine-stricken people in eastern Europe and the Soviet Union.

Hoover was the Secretary of Commerce under prior Presidents William G. Harding and Calvin Coolidge. In 1927, he appeared in the first American demonstration of television.

In 1928, he became the Republican presidential nominee. He ran against Al Smith, a New York Democrat supported by FDR, but Smith was the nation's first Catholic presidential candidate, which triggered demonstrations by the Ku Klux Klan. He also supported the repeal of Prohibition, which made many believe he was an alcoholic. Hoover ran and won on the theme of the nation's prosperity during the Roaring Twenties. His campaign slogan was "A Chicken for Every Pot."

As president, Hoover received a $75,000 salary. It would be worth $2.1 million today. Hoover divided his salary between various charities. He also gave some to his staff. Hoover's net worth was around $4 million in 1913, worth $103 million today.

After Leaving Office

Hoover became the scapegoat for the Depression and was badly defeated in 1932. He criticized the New Deal as fascist because it made the federal government too powerful.

During World War II, FDR appointed Hoover to send food relief to German-occupied nations. He opposed entry into the war, especially the use of the atom bomb.

In 1946, President Truman appointed Hoover to coordinate efforts to prevent a global famine. In 1947, he chaired a commission that strengthened Truman's Executive Departments. In 1955, he chaired a similar commission for President Eisenhower.

Hoover was an outspoken critic of U.S. military intervention overseas. He thought military spending would bankrupt America.

Hoover wrote a three-volume autobiography of his life through 1941. He also published four volumes of presidential papers and eight volumes of speeches. His other popular books include "American Individualism," "The Challenge to Liberty," "The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson," "Business Cycles and Unemployment," and "Freedom Betrayed." In 1964, he died at 90 of colon cancer.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What was President Herbert Hoover's philosophical approach to the economy?

President Hoover believed in laissez-faire economics. He vetoed legislation that would have provided direct support to Americans, because he felt that it wasn't a proper use of government funds. However, Hoover occasionally strayed from laissez-faire policies, such as when he raised income tax rates in 1932.

How did FDR's economic policies differ from those of Hoover?

President Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal legislation enacted many of the social programs that President Hoover had opposed, such as direct aid to unemployed Americans. However, the two presidents did share some economic ideas when it came to securing the financial system. For example, the Emergency Banking Relief Act signed by FDR closely resembled legislation introduced by Hoover in the lame-duck congressional session just before FDR took office.

Article Sources

  1. WhiteHouse.gov. "Herbert Hoover."

  2. History, Art & Archives, United States House of Representatives. "The Designation of the “Star-Spangled Banner."

  3. The University of Houston. "Digital History: Chapter 7, Herbert Hoover and the Depression."

  4. The Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History. "Herbert Hoover on the Great Depression and New Deal, 1931-1933."

  5. Tax Policy Center. "Historical Highest Marginal Income Tax Rates."

  6. History. "Herbert Hoover."

  7. UVA Miller Center. "December 9, 1930: Message Regarding Unemployment Relief."

  8. Bureau of Economic Analysis. “National Income and Product Accounts Tables: Table 1.1.1. GDP Growth,” Select “Modify,” Select “First Year 1929,” Select “Series Annual,” Select “Refresh Table.”

  9. 1929 - 1947: Bureau of Labor Statistics. "Labor Force, Employment, and Unemployment, 1929-39: Estimating Methods,” Unemployed divided by Civilian Labor Force. Table 1.

  10. World Trade Organization. “World Trade Report,” Figure B.2. Page 52.

  11. Encyclopedia Britannica. "Reconstruction Finance Corporation."

  12. CQ Press. "The R.F.C. Under Hoover and Roosevelt."

  13. The National Bureau of Economic Research. "The Effects of Reconstruction Finance Corporation Assistance on Michigan's Banks' Survival in the 1930s."

  14. UC Santa Barbara. "The American Presidency Project, Statement on Signing the Revenue Act of 1932."

  15. The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. "Monetary Policy and the Great Crash of 1929: A Bursting Bubble or Collapsing Fundamentals?"

  16. History. "Bank Run."

  17. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. "Reserve Requirements."

  18. University of Nebraska, National Drought Mitigation Center. "The Dust Bowl."

  19. History. "Hoovervilles."

  20. History. "World War I."

  21. Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. "Rising Federal Debt Should Not Shortchange Response to COVID-19 Crisis."

  22. History. "10 Things You May Not Know About Herbert Hoover."

  23. Biography. "Herbert Hoover Biography."

  24. State Historical Society of Iowa. "'A Chicken for Every Pot' Political Ad, October 30, 1928."

  25. The Philanthropy Roundtable. "Herbert Hoover."

  26. The University of Virginia. "Herbert Hoover: Life After the Presidency."

  27. Herbert Hoover Presidential Library and Museum. "The Published Writings of Herbert Hoover."

  28. Amazon. "American Individualism," Hoover Institution Press, 2016.

  29. George H Nash. "Freedom Betrayed: Herbert Hoover's Secret History of the Second World War and Its Aftermath." Hoover Institution Press/Amazon. 2011.

  30. Amazon. "Business Cycles And Unemployment," Palala Press, 2015.

  31. Amazon. "The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson." Woodrow Wilson Center Press,1992.

  32. Amazon. "The Challenge to Liberty," C. Scribner's Sons, 1935.

  33. The New York Times. "The Learning Network."

  34. The White House. "Franklin D. Roosevelt."

  35. Herbert Hoover Presidential Library and Museum. "The Great Depression."