Is the Real Estate Market Going to Crash?
Many Americans may be worried about a real estate market crash. They are concerned about the impact of the coronavirus pandemic on housing prices. The 2020 stock market crash has worsend those fears. Is the housing market next?
In April 2020, the National Association of Realtors surveyed its members. About 90% said the pandemic has reduced home buyer interest. Of those, 60% are simply delaying their purchase for a couple of months. Almost two-thirds of buyers (63%) expect lower prices.
The best way to predict a crash is to look for these 10 warning signs. Some of these have occurred, but many haven’t. The first five are the most important. If all 10 occur in a rapid fashion, then a crash is more likely.
- Asset bubble bursts
- Increase of unregulated mortgages
- Rapidly rising interest rates
- Inverted yield curve
- Change to the federal tax code
- Return to risky derivatives
- Greater number of house flippers
- Fewer affordable homes
- Rising sea levels
- Warnings from officials
10 Warning Signs of a Crash
There are 10 signs of a housing market crash. The first five are critical. They are when an asset bubble has burst, an increase of unregulated mortgages, rapidly rising interest rates, an inverted yield curve, and a change to the federal tax code.
The other five signs could contribute to a crash, but are less critical. They include greater number of house flippers, warnings, fewer affordable homes, and a return to risky derivatives.
Let’s look at each more closely.
1. Asset Bubbles Burst
Most crashes occur when an asset bubble has burst. One sign of a potential bubble is rapidly rising home prices. The national average home price hit a record high of $212,433 in January 2020. This was 15% higher than the July 2006 record high of $184,613, according to the Case Shiller Home Price Index. Similarly, the S&P Homebuilders Select Industry Index has risen dramatically. It rose 250%, from 1,372.60 on October 5, 2011, to 4,867 on February 12, 2020. Since then, it's fallen by half to 2,486 on March 23, 2020.
The Housing Bellwether Barometer is an index of homebuilders and mortgage companies. In 2017, it skyrocketed like it did in 2004 and 2005. That's according to its creator, James Stack of Stack Financial Management, in an interview with Marketwatch. Stack used the indicator to predict the 2008 financial crisis.
2. Increase in Unregulated Mortgage Brokers
Another concern is the increase in unregulated mortgage brokers. In 2018, they originated 53.6% of U.S. mortgages. Five of the 10 largest mortgage lenders are not banks. They aren't as regulated as banks. That makes them more vulnerable to collapse if the housing market softens again.
3. Rising Interest Rates
Higher interest rates make loans more expensive. That slows home building and decreases its supply. It also slows lending, which cuts back on demand. Overall, a slow and steady interest rate increase won't create a catastrophe. But quickly rising rates will.
The Federal Reserve has lowered interest rates to zero to help businesses during the coronavirus pandemic. It should help the housing market, too.
Higher interest rates preceded the housing collapse in 2006. Many borrowers then had interest-only loans and adjustable-rate mortgages. Unlike a conventional loan, the interest rates rise along with the fed funds rate. Many also had introductory teaser rates that reset after three years. When the Federal Reserve raised rates at the same time they reset, borrowers found they could no longer afford the payments. Home prices had fallen, so these mortgage-holders couldn't make the payments or sell the house. As a result, default rates rose.
The history of the fed funds rate reveals that the Fed raised rates too fast between 2004 and 2006. The top rate was 1.0% in June 2004 and doubled to 2.25% by December. It doubled again to 4.25% by December 2005. Six months later, the rate was 5.25%. The Fed raised rates at a much slower pace since 2015.
4. Inverted Yield Curve
A warning sign for the real estate market is when the yield curve on U.S. Treasury notes inverts. That's when the interest rates for short-term Treasurys become higher than long-term yields. Normal short-term yields are lower because investors don't require a high return to invest for less than a year. When that inverts, it means investors think the short-term is riskier than the long-term. That plays havoc with the mortgage market and often signals a recession.
5. Changes to the Tax Code
The housing market responds dramatically when Congress changes the tax code. Trump’s tax reform plan could be having a negative impact on housing. The plan raised the standard deduction, so many Americans no longer need to itemize. As a result, they can’t take advantage of the mortgage interest deduction. The real estate industry opposed the tax plan.
6. Banks Return to Using Derivatives
The real estate market could collapse if banks and hedge funds returned to investing in risky financial products. These derivatives were a major cause of the financial crisis. Banks sliced up mortgages and resold them in mortgage-backed securities. These securities were a bigger business than the mortgages themselves. So, banks sold mortgages to just about anyone. They needed them to support the derivatives. They sliced them up so that bad mortgages were hidden in bundles with good ones. Then when borrowers defaulted, all the derivatives were suspected of being bad. This phenomenon caused the demise of Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers.
7. Increase in “Flipped” Homes
In the second quarter of 2019, 5.9% of all home sales were bought for quick resale. These "flip" homes were renovated and sold in less than a year. That's down from the post-recession high of 7.2% in first-quarter 2019. Attom Data Solutions reports that flipping is becoming less profitable, a sign that the housing boom may be coming to an end.
8. Affordable Housing Plummets
At the same time, affordable housing plummets. In 2017, only 39.1% of rental units across the country were affordable for low-income households. That's down from 55.7% in 2010. The shortage is the worst in cities where home prices have soared. For example, housing costs have increased by 30% between 2012 and 2017 in Colorado, while wages only rose by 15%. The population increased 14.5% between 2010 and 2019, much faster than the national average of 6.3%. Many residents believe part of the increase is due to the state’s legalization of pot in 2012.
9. Rising Sea Levels
Real estate markets could collapse in coastal regions vulnerable to the effects of rising sea levels. At least 300,000 coastal properties will flood 26 times a year by 2045. The value of that real estate is $136 billion. That affects the value of 30-year mortgages currently being written. By 2100, 2.5 million homes worth $1.07 trillion will be at risk of chronic flooding. Properties on both coasts are at most risk.
In Miami, Florida, the ocean floods the streets during high tide. Harvard researchers found that home prices in lower-lying areas of Miami-Dade County and Miami Beach are rising more slowly than the rest of Florida. Properties at risk of rising sea levels sell at a 7% discount to comparable properties.
Most of the property in these cities are financed by municipal bonds or home mortgages. Their destruction will hurt the investors and depress the bond market. Markets could collapse in these regions, especially after severe storms.
10. Officials Warn of a Housing Crisis
In March 2017, William Poole, a former president of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, in an op-ed warned of another subprime crisis. He warned that 36% of Fannie Mae's loans required mortgage insurance. That's about the level in 2006. Poole was the head of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas who warned of the subprime crisis in 2005.
What We Can Learn From the 2008 Housing Market Crash
People who were caught in the 2008 crash may be spooked that the pandemic will lead to another crash. But the 2008 crash was caused by forces that are no longer present.
First, insurance companies created credit default swaps that protected investors from losses in derivatives such as mortgage-backed securities.
To meet this demand for mortgages, banks and mortgage brokers offered home loans to just about anyone. They didn't care about the credit-worthiness of subprime mortgage borrowers. Banks simply resold the mortgages on the secondary market. This created greater risk in the financial markets.
The entrance of so many unqualified buyers into the market sent prices soaring. Many people bought homes only as investments. They exhibited irrational exuberance, a hallmark of any asset bubble.
In 2005, homebuilders finally caught up with demand. When supply outpaced demand, housing prices started to fall. New home prices fell 22% from their peak of $262,600 in March 2007 to $204,200 in October 2010. That burst the bubble.
But the Fed ignored these warnings. The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission found that the Fed should have set prudent mortgage-lending standards. Instead, it only lowered interest rates. That generally gives the economy enough liquidity to fuel growth.
The Fed underestimated the size and impact of the subprime mortgage crisis in 2006. Many of the subprime purchasers were individual investors, pension funds, and retirement funds. They invested more heavily in hedge funds, spreading the risk throughout the economy.
National Association of Realtors. "2020 NAR Flash Survey: Economic Pulse, April 5-6, 2020," Download PDF. Accessed April 11, 2020.
Federal Reserve of St. Louis. "S&P/Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index," Accessed April 11, 2020.
S&P Dow Jones Indices, "S&P Homebuilders Index," Accessed April 11, 2020.
MarketWatch. "This Veteran Investor Nailed the Last Housing Bubble and Now Expects Another," Accessed April 11, 2020.
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. "Data Point: 2018 Mortgage Market Activity and Trends," Page 58. Accessed April 11, 2020.
HousingWire. "Here Are the Top 10 Mortgage Lenders of 2018," Accessed April 11, 2020.
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. "Federal Funds Target Rate Upper Limit," April 11, 2020.
National Association of Home Builders. "NAHB Opposes Tax Reform Plan," Accessed April 11, 2020.
Attom Data Solutions. "U.S. Home Flipping Returns Drop to Nearly Eight-Year Low in Q2 2019," Accessed April 11, 2020.
FreddieMac. "The Diminishing Supply of Affordable Units," Download PDF. Page 1. Accessed April 11, 2020.
FreddieMac. "The Diminishing Supply of Affordable Units," Download PDF. Page 6. Accessed April 11, 2020.
U.S. Census Bureau. "Quick Facts," Enter "Colorado," Select Population, Percent Change 2010 to 2019," Accessed Dec. 31, 2019.
Union of Concerned Scientists. "Underwater," Page 2. Accessed April 11, 2020.
IOPScience. "Climate Gentrification: From Theory to Empiricism in Miami-Dade County, Florida," Accessed April 11, 2020.
The University of Colorado Boulder. "Disaster on the Horizon: The Price Effect of Sea Level Rise," Accessed April 11, 2020.
CNN. "Are We Heading Toward Another Subprime Mortgage Crisis?" Accessed April 11, 2020.
National Bureau of Economic Research. "Has Financial Development Made the World Riskier?" Page 4. Accessed April 11, 2020.
Federal Reserve Bank of New York. "The Supply Side of the Housing Boom and Bust of the 2000s," Page 6. Accessed April 11, 2020.
U.S Census. "Median and Average Sales Prices of New Homes Sold in United States," Accessed April 11, 2020.
Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission. "The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report," Page xvii. Accessed April 11, 2020.
Securities and Exchange Commission. "The Subprime Crisis’ Impact on Fixed-Income Funds," Page 5. Accessed April 11, 2020.