Investing in Low-Cost Index Funds

Reasons to Consider Adding Low-Cost Index Funds to Your Portfolio

Business people reviewing financial data on digital tablet
••• Hero Images / Getty Images

As you embark on your journey to build wealth through investing in mutual funds, you may wonder which to choose: actively managed mutual funds or passively managed mutual funds.

According to the Motley Fool, only 10 of the 10,000 actively managed mutual funds available have beaten the S&P 500 consistently over the course of the past ten years. History tells us that very few if any of these funds will manage the same feat in the decade to come.

The lesson is simple: Unless you are convinced that you are capable of selecting the 0.001 percent of mutual funds that are going to beat the broad market, you would best be served by investing in the market itself.

The "market" is represented by the S&P 500 index, so you would basically invest mutual funds that replicate the holdings (and returns) of the S&P 500.

You can also take this strategy a step further by beginning a dollar-cost averaging plan into low-cost index funds. With this approach, you can be certain you will out-perform a majority of managed mutual funds on a long-term basis.

Indeed, the most successful investor in history, Warren Buffett, advocates that those unwilling or unable to effectively evaluate individual stocks should invest in a low-cost index fund such as those offered by Vanguard.

Why? Index funds boast three distinct advantages over their actively-managed counterparts:

  • They do not require corporate analysis or an understanding of accounting, financial theory, or portfolio policy.
  • They have almost non-existent expense ratios, providing a significant competitive edge over actively managed funds and almost completely ensuring superior long-term performance.
  • They are made up of dozens or hundreds of companies. This diversification reduces company-specific risk.

What Is An Index Fund?

Before you add an index fund to your portfolio, it's import to understand what it is. An index fund is a mutual fund designed to mirror the performance of one of the major indices (e.g., the Dow Jones Industrial Average, S&P 500, Wilshire 5000, Russell 2000, etc.) Unlike traditional, actively managed mutual funds where portfolio managers evaluate, analyze and acquire individual stocks, index funds are passively managed. Basically, this means they consist of a pre-selected group of stocks that rarely, if ever, changes.

An investor that bought an index fund designed to mirror the Dow Jones Industrial Average, for example, would experience price movements almost perfectly in sync with the quoted value of the Dow Jones Industrial Average he hears on the nightly news.

Likewise, an investor who built a position in an index fund designed to mimic the S&P 500 is, in essence, acquiring stock in all five hundred of the companies that make up that index.

Skip the Corporate and Financial Analysis Requirement

Index funds are ideal for those who have no idea how to evaluate competitive advantages of various corporations, differentiate an income statement from a balance sheet, or calculate discounted cash flows. Because company-specific risk is diversified away thanks to the dozens or hundreds of companies that make up each of the major indices, such analysis is not necessary. Also, an index fund is a cost-effective way to acquire hundreds of stocks while avoiding the thousands of dollars in brokerage commissions that would otherwise result.

Take Advantage of the Lowest Mutual Fund Expense Ratios

Actively managed mutual funds must pay portfolio managers, analysts, research subscription fees and the like. The percentage of a fund's total expenses including its 12b-1 fees divided by its average net assets is known as the expense ratio. Because index funds are non-managed (and require none of the aforementioned expenses), the expense ratio is almost nil compared to the average mutual fund. It means that less of the investor's money goes to paying overhead, compensation, and sales charges. Over the long run, the lower costs associated with index funds can result in significantly improved performance.

Consider the following: A quick glance at Yahoo Finance reveals the average expense ratio for growth and income style mutual funds is 1.29 percent. As a result, approximately $1,883 of every $10,000 invested over the course of ten years will go to the fund company in the form of expenses.

Compare that to the Vanguard 500 fund, designed to mirror the S&P 500 index, which boasts an annual expense ratio of only 0.12 percent, resulting in a ten-year compounded expense of $154 for every $10,000 invested. In other words, by investing in the Vanguard fund, the investor will have $1,724 more money working for him instead of going to cover fees. Compounded over an investing lifetime, the difference is significant.

Index Fund Investing Paired With Long-Term Dollar Cost Averaging

At the height of the roaring stock market of the 1920s, the Dow Jones Industrial Average reached a peak of 381.17. In 1932, the Dow crashed to 42.22. It took over thirty-three years (1929 to 1955) for it to return to the 1929 level. An individual investing all of his money at the height would have waited more than three decades to break even!

If, however, he had started a dollar-cost averaging program, he would have made a tremendous amount of money thanks to his significantly lower average cost basis by the time the market returned to its previous level. Combined with reinvested dividends, he would have broken even in only a few years, and by the time the market reached its former level, would have done very well.