What to Do If You Are At-Fault in an Accident

The Accident Was Your Fault...Now What?

Man and woman talking to each other between their cars after an accident.

Guido Mieth / Getty Images

Being in a car accident can be devastating on many levels. And if you're the at-fault driver, it can really add to the stress of the situation. Not only do you have to deal with the damage to your own vehicle, but you also have to work with the other party involved.

What actions should you take right after you caused an accident? How will it affect your car insurance? Learn what you need to know what you're the at-fault driver in a car accident.

Key Takeaways

  • If you cause a car accident, call the police, and report the incident to your insurance carrier. 
  • An accident will typically increase your auto insurance rates. 
  • If you haven’t gotten into an accident, you may be able to add accident forgiveness to your policy and avoid rate increases.

5 Steps to Take After Causing a Car Accident

  1. Always stop and check for injuries in both your vehicle and any other vehicles involved. If there are any serious injuries, call 911.
  2. Exchange information with any other drivers involved. The information should include name, phone number, insurance carrier and agency, and insurance policy number. Also, be sure to note the time and location of the accident.
  3. Report the accident to the police. In some cities, you can do this by calling 311, and other times, you’ll need to place a regular 911 call. Do not leave the scene until the police arrive.
  4. Document, document, document. Take as many photos at the scene of the accident as you can. Take photos of both your car and the other person’s car so that no one can change the story later on.
  5. Report the accident directly to your car insurance agent or insurance carrier.

It may be tempting to avoid calling the police, but it is standard procedure. Causing a car accident is upsetting, but it's best to take responsibility and make the situation as smooth as possible.

A police report is important for the not-at-fault party and will clarify any questions of responsibility for the insurance company. The at-fault driver may receive a traffic ticket for causing an accident.

How Does Causing a Car Accident Affect Your Auto Insurance?

Regardless of whether or not you receive a ticket from the police, if you were more than 50% at-fault, then your car insurance rates will probably be increased when your policy renews.

Insurance carriers always determine the at-fault driver in a car accident. Insurance carriers can surcharge your car insurance if you receive a traffic violation for the accident or if you file a claim and are determined at-fault. The normal procedure is for only one of the occurrences to go against you, meaning you will not be charged for the traffic violation plus the claim.

Some auto insurance policies offer accident forgiveness if you’ve gone a certain amount of time without causing an accident. This is something to look into before—not after—an accident.

Car Insurance Deductibles and Coverage

After causing a car accident, you might be wondering how your car insurance policy will cover you. Damages to your vehicle will be covered by your policy if you purchased collision coverage.

You will be responsible for your deductible, meaning that you must pay for damages until you reach the deductible amount, and anything above your deductible will be covered by your policy.

In most states, your insurance policy will also cover the damage to the not-at-fault vehicle. Medical coverage varies by state. Some states get coverage from the at-fault party’s policy, while other no-fault states look to their own policy regardless of who is at fault.

How to Avoid Car Insurance Increases

The best way to get around a car insurance increase after an at-fault accident is to purchase accident forgiveness ahead of time. Not all insurance carriers offer accident forgiveness, but more and more are coming out with the feature.

Usually, for a small fee, you can add accident forgiveness to your car insurance policy. Then, if you are in an at-fault accident, your rates will not increase due to the accident.