What Is Educational Equity and Why Does It Matter
Why Equity Is Better Than Equality for the Economy
Equity in education is when every student receives the resources needed to acquire the basic work skills of reading, writing, and simple arithmetic. It measures educational success in society by its outcome, not the resources poured into it.
The COVID-19 pandemic has made achieving educational equity even more challenging. In many areas, schools have shut down to slow the spread of the virus. This worsened racial disparities, as many low-income families don't have the wifi connections or computer equipment needed for long-distance learning. A McKinsey study showed that, as a result, students of color were an additional three to five months behind in math, while white students were one to three months behind.
Inequity in education slows economic growth as much as recessions. Students that don't receive the educational resources they need can't perform at their optimal level. They don't earn as much, can't build wealth, and therefore can't afford to send their children to good schools. This continues a cycle of structural inequality that hurts society as a whole.
Defining Educational Equity
Educational equity means the educational system gives each student what he or she needs to perform at an acceptable level.
According to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), equity in education has two dimensions that are closely intertwined.
- The first is fairness. It means making sure that personal and social circumstances are not obstacles to achieving educational potential. It prohibits discrimination based on gender, ethnic origin, or socioeconomic status.
- The second is inclusion. It ensures a basic minimum standard of education for all. For example, everyone should be able to read, write, and do simple arithmetic. If some students need more to get there, they should receive it.
Equity should not be confused with educational equality which means providing each student the equivalent resources. Even if every school district gets the same level of funding, it might not be enough to help some students achieve the same level of proficiency. Equality is better than discrimination, but it may not be enough to provide equity.
The Impact of Inequity in Education
Equity in education is necessary for economic mobility. Without it, the economy will suffer from an achievement gap between groups in society. As students aren't prepared to achieve their working potential, it created income inequality. This, in turn, creates a wealth gap.
Parents on the lower wealth tiers can't afford to send their children to the expensive, quality schools that those on higher tiers can. This contributes to structural inequality, where the institutions themselves contribute to inequality. As a result, inequity in education means that a society loses the income and economic output potential of the lower-income tiers. That slows economic growth for everyone.
In the United States, inequity in education has created an achievement gap between races. A 2009 McKinsey study found that the average score of Black and Hispanic students on standardized tests was two to three years behind that of White students of the same age.
The achievement gap caused by inequity in education has cost the U.S. economy more than all recessions since 1970.
McKinsey estimated that, if there had been no achievement gap in the years between 1998 and 2008, U.S. gross domestic product would have been $525 billion higher in 2008. Similarly, if low-income students had the same educational achievement as their wealthier peers over that same period, they would have added $670 billion in GDP.
Education and Income
Inequity in education has increased income inequality in America. Over a lifetime, workers with college degrees earn 84% more than those with only high school. Those with master's degrees or higher earn 131% more than high school graduates.
Despite this clear economic advantage, fewer than half of Americans age 25-34 have at least a university-level education. Nine other countries, including Korea, Russia, and Canada, rank higher.
One reason is that higher education costs so much in the United States. According to the College Board, one year of a state school is $10,560 for state residents and $27,020 for out of state students. Private non-profit education costs $37,650 a year. U.S. education is the second-highest in the world, after Luxembourg, according to the OECD.
Education and Wealth
A 2018 Federal Reserve study found there are three ways education creates wealth. First, families headed by educated parents earn more than those without college degrees. That gives the children a head start in life. They can attend private schools and receive better education themselves.
Second, is the upward-mobility effect. It occurs when a child is born into a family without a college degree. Once the child earns a diploma, the entire family becomes wealthier. The study found it boosted family wealth by 20 percentiles. In families where both the parents and child graduated from college, wealth improved but only by 11 percentiles.
The third is the downward-mobility effect. Children whose parents didn't graduate from college fell 10 percentiles in wealth. Children with college-educated parents who didn't graduate college did worse. They fell 18 percentiles in wealth.
Inequity in education has led to structural inequality. Students in low-income neighborhoods receive an inferior education than students in wealthier areas. Research has found that this accounts for 37% of the reason for their lower math scores. Structural inequality exists where poor children must attend public schools while rich children can afford to attend higher-quality private schools.
"Because of school differences in content exposure for low- and high-income students in this country, the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer,” said William Schmidt, the Distinguished professor of statistics and education at Michigan State University. "The belief that schools are the great equalizer, helping students overcome the inequalities of poverty, is a myth," he added.
How to Achieve Equity in Education
The OECD recommends 10 steps to improve equity in education. Among these are:
Improve the Educational System's Design
The first four steps improve the design of educational systems. School districts must make sure each school has the resources it needs for its students. This includes everything from Special Education to Gifted and Talented students.
The school system routinely assigns children from an early age to either college-bound or vocational tracks. This often discriminates by gender, race, and income. Instead, the OECD says tracking should be delayed or even eliminated.
Poor-performers should be given extra training so they can "catch up." This includes GED programs. Vocational workers should also receive a college education so they can manage in higher-tech manufacturing.
In the Classroom
The OECD's steps fifth through seventh steps target the classroom level. Students should receive a personalized education based on their needs.
- Instead of failing students, give them intense intervention in specific skill areas. This will increase graduation rates.
- Work with parents more to get their support of their child's schoolwork. If this is impossible, then provide after-school programs for those children.
- Help immigrants and minority children attend mainstream schools. If needed, give them intense language training.
A University of Michigan study found an 11th solution that was both inexpensive and effective. Researchers sent invitations to high-performing, low-income high school students. It promised scholarships to pay for all costs. More than two-thirds applied to the university compared to 28% in a control group that didn't receive the invitation.
Target Resources to Those Most in Need
The OECD's steps eight through 10 suggest targeting scarce school funding to those most in need. The United States does the opposite. A U.S. Department of Education study found that 45% of high-poverty schools received less state and local funding than the average for other schools in their district. Similarly, the states that are wealthier have better education scores.
Step eight is to focus on early childhood education. The ninth recommendation says to give grants to children in low-income families to keep them in school. The federal government offers Pell Grants to low-income students attending college. Step 10 is to set school targets for student skill levels and school dropout rates. Focus resources on those schools with the worst scores.
- Equity in education is not the same as an equal education.
- Equity is necessary for economic mobility.
- The cost of inequity is more than all recessions combined.
- The OECD recommends 10 steps to provide equity in education.
McKinsey and Company. "COVID-10 and Learning Loss - Disparities Grow and Students Need Help. " Accessed January 18, 2021.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). "Ten Step to Equity in Education." Accessed January 18, 2021.
The Education Trust. "Equity and Equality Are Not Equal." Accessed January 18, 2021.
McKinsey & Company. "The Economic Cost of the US Education Gap." Accessed January 18, 2021.
Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce. "The College Payoff." Accessed January 18, 2021.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). "Education at a Glance 2019." Accessed January 18, 2021.
College Board. "Trends in College Pricing: Highlights." Accessed January 18, 2021.
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. "The Financial Returns from College Across Generations: Large But Unequal." Accessed January 18, 2021.
Michigan State University. "Schools Worsen Inequality, Especially in Math Instruction." Accessed January 18, 2021.
University of Michigan Ford School. "HAILed it—Tuition-Free Promise Attracts Low-Income Students to U-M." Accessed January 18, 2021.
U.S. Department of Education. "Comparability of State and Local Expenditures Among Schools Within Districts: A Report From the Study of School-Level Expenditures," Pages 18-28. Accessed January 18, 2021.
Education Next. "America's Mediocre Test Scores." Accessed Dec. 23, 2020.
U.S. Department of Education. "Federal Pell Grants Are Usually Awarded Only to Undergraduate Students." Accessed Dec. 23, 2020.