The Balance
Do I Need Comprehensive Coverage?
  • Investing
    • Basics
    • Stocks
    • Real Estate
    • Value Investing
    • View All
  • Credit & Debt
    • Building Credit
    • Credit Card Basics
    • Reducing Debt
    • Reports & Scores
    • View All
  • Retirement Planning
    • Basics
    • 401(k) Plans
    • IRAs
    • Social Security
    • View All
  • Banking & Loans
    • Basics
    • Best Savings Account Rates
    • Getting a Loan
    • Online Banking
    • View All
visit our other sites
Policy Fundamentals
  • Rules of Thumb
  • Ways to Save
    Car Insurance & Loans Policy Fundamentals

    Do I Need Comprehensive Coverage?

    • Share
    • Flip
    • Pin
    • Email
    By Emily Delbridge
    Updated February 15, 2017

    Determining whether you need comprehensive coverage on your vehicle is not a difficult task. Begin by understanding what comprehensive coverage actually covers. Comprehensive coverage covers a broad spectrum of potential physical damage claims. It includes coverage for vandalism, contact with an animal, windshield damage and more.​

    5 Things to Consider when deciding to Purchase Comprehensive Coverage.

  • 01
    Is comprehensive coverage required by state law?

    Fallen tree on a car, Washington DC, USA
    Glowimages/Getty Images

    State car insurance laws do not require physical damage coverage on vehicles. Although state laws vary by state, nearly all states require liability and property damage coverage.

  • 02
    Do you have a loan on the vehicle?

    Lenders require full coverage insurance on vehicles they financed. Comprehensive is part of the mandatory coverage. When you sign your loan papers, you agree to protect the vehicle against physical damage by purchasing both comprehensive and collision.

    Failure to notify your lender of your insurance coverage can create expensive penalties for yourself. Ask your insurance agent to list your lender as loss payee on your vehicle. By doing so, your insurance carrier will automatically notify your lender of your coverage.

  • 03
    What is your level of risk for having a comprehensive claim?

    Do you float down country roads at dusk bowling for deer? Do you park your car every night under a half dead 40ft tall tree? Do you live in tornado alley? All of these things put you at a high risk for having a comprehensive claim. Evaluate your circumstances. If you live in the city and have never seen a deer in your life, your risk of hitting one with your car is slim. If you park in your garage every night and park in a parking ramp during the day, storm damage is not likely. The lower your risk is for a claim, the better off you would be without the coverage altogether.

  • 04
    What is the value of your vehicle?

    Knowing the value of your vehicle will help you determine if it is worth it to pay for comprehensive coverage. Check Kelly Blue Book and N.A.D.A. to get a good estimate of your vehicle’s value.

  • 05
    How much does comprehensive coverage cost?

    The great thing about comprehensive coverage is it is typically reasonably priced. As long as you are not a high risk driver, comprehensive can be well worth the price. Even an older vehicle with minimal value is probably still worth a windshield replacement. Determine how much you pay for comprehensive coverage by checking with your insurance agent, or your declaration page.

    The argument could go either way when it comes to comprehensive coverage. Being such a versatile coverage makes it hard to give up. Anytime you remove coverage from your car insurance policy the motive is to save money. Unfortunately without a crystal ball, you do not know if you will have a claim in the near future. Removing comprehensive coverage is the right choice for many car owners, but the question you need to answer is whether or not it is right for you.

  • Young man leaning on crashed car, low section

    Do I Need Collision Coverage on My Insurance Policy?

  • exchanging insurance details

    What You Need to Know About a Proof of Insurance Card for Your Vehicle

  • Damaged bumpers from car accident

    Know Your Car Coverage: Key Points to Comprehensive and Collision

  • USA, Georgia, Atlanta, traffic on I-85 at night (long exposure)

    Consider Yourself Warned: Do Not Drive Without Insurance in GA

  • Two men arguing about damaged cars

    The Definition of Full Coverage Auto Insurance and What It Covers

  • Major Car Accident

    Crazy Important Insurance Terminology: Actual Cash Value

  • a woman in drivers seat of a car, laughing with a friend

    What to Know About Insuring a Salvage Title Vehicle in New York

  • Moving Out of State

    Do Not Forget About Your Car Insurance When You Move

  • Car accident with injuries

    Michigan Catastrophic Claims Fee Changes Annually

  • Midsection Of Man Signing Car Insurance Form

    Can I Get Temporary Car Insurance in California?

  • Car Repossession

    How Much Car Insurance Is Required by the State of New Jersey?

  • Protection of the family property

    How Do I Find Out if I Have Car Insurance?

  • African teenager in car with father

    What to Know About Getting Car Insurance for First-Time Driver

  • Car key on pile of one hundred dollar bills

    What is a Loss Payee on an Insurance Policy?

  • Two men arguing about damaged cars

    Reasons You Need Car Insurance (Even if You Do Not Own a Car)

  • Two car collision

    The Requirements for Insuring a Vehicle With a Salvage Title

Our Best Money Tips, Delivered
You're in! Thanks for signing up.
There was an error. Please try again.
Facebook Pinterest Twitter Flipboard Linkedin
  • Investing
  • Credit & Debt
  • Retirement Planning
  • Banking & Loans
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Editorial Guidelines
Also from The Balance Team
The Balance Small Business
The Balance Careers
The Balance is part of the Dotdash publishing family.
  • Lifewire
  • ThoughtCo
  • TripSavvy
  • The Spruce
  • and more