Democratic Presidents' Impact on the U.S. Economy
From Woodrow Wilson to Barack Obama
Since World War I, there have been eight Democratic presidents. Democrats are known to prefer government spending over tax cuts (especially for the wealthy) as a way to boost the economy. The exception is for defense, where Democrats are considered weaker than Republicans. They don't worry as much about balancing the budget as Republicans do. But these eight presidents did not all follow these stereotypes.
Here is an analysis of these eight presidents and their major economic achievements. You’ll be able to see how much they followed the economic policies of their party. Most of them responded with expansionary fiscal policy to pull the country out of a recession or depression. Many also had to increase defense spending for wars.
Woodrow Wilson (1913-1921)
Wilson signed the Underwood-Simmons Act in 1913. It reduced tariffs on manufactured goods and raw materials. This lowered costs for consumers. To compensate for the loss in revenue, it also created a graduated federal income tax. Most workers at that time made too little to get hit with the tax. The reduction in tariffs did not immediately reduce the cost of imports. That's because World War I broke out the following year, reducing European production.
In 1914, Wilson instructed Congress to create the Clayton Anti-Trust Act. It expanded on the Sherman Act to limit monopolies' power. It established the Federal Trade Commission, which enforces these laws.
Germany sank the British ocean liner Lusitania in 1915. Wilson warned any further attacks would cause the United States to enter World War I. He declared war on April 6, 1917, after Germany attacked U.S. merchant ships. (Source: "Woodrow Wilson," History.com.)
In 1916, Wilson signed three acts while gearing up for the war. First, the Adamson Act created the eight-hour workday for railroad workers. Wilson wanted to avoid a strike by the railroad unions while the country was gearing up for World War I. That set the standard for Ford Motor Company to do the same 10 years later. The Federal Farm Loan Act set up government loans to farmers to develop and expand their farms. He also signed the Keating-Owen Act. It banned articles produced by child labor from being sold in interstate commerce.
The Supreme Court declared it unconstitutional two years later.
Germany surrendered in 1918. Wilson brokered the Treaty of Versailles in 1919, which called for the establishment of the League of Nations. But, the Republicans in Congress defeated it. He received a Nobel Prize for his efforts to promote peace. (Source: "Woodrow Wilson," White House.)
Wilson vetoed the Volstead Act, which enforced the 18th Amendment prohibiting alcohol in 1919. He advocated for the 19th Amendment giving women the right to vote in 1920.
President Wilson was the second-largest contributor to the debt percentage-wise. He added $21 billion, which was a 727 percent increase over the $2.9 billion debt of his predecessor. That was because of World War I. During his presidency, the Second Liberty Bond Act gave Congress the right to adopt the national debt ceiling. To compare Wilson to all other modern presidents, see U.S. Debt by President.
Franklin Roosevelt was sworn in at the height of the Great Depression. He had won the election by promising a New Deal to end it. He introduced Keynesian economic theory, which said government spending would end a recession.
President Hoover had practiced laissez-faire economics, and done little to intervene. He believed a free market would bounce back on its own. Instead, the economy shrank more than 10 percent and unemployment rose to 25 percent. For more, see Effects of the Great Depression.
FDR rallied Americans around government spending. He created 42 new agencies to safeguard investments, create jobs and allow unionization. They included Social Security, the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. He also passed the U.S. minimum wage and child labor laws.
The stock market crash of 1929 turned investors away from stocks and toward gold. As the price of gold rose, people redeemed their dollars for it. That's because the United States adhered to the gold standard. The Federal Reserve raised interest rates to defend the dollar's value. Banks began failing.
FDR ordered Americans to turn in their gold coins to banks in exchange for dollars. He closed banks to stop foreign speculators from depleting America's gold deposits. Ten days later, banks reopened after depositing all their gold with the Federal Reserve.
In 1934, FDR took the United States off the gold standard. The dollar fell by 60 percent. The government could then print enough money to boost growth, since dollars were no longer tied to gold. (Source: "The Rise and Fall of the Gold Standard in the U.S." Cato Institute, June 20, 2013.)
The New Deal stopped the Depression by 1936. But then FDR decided to cut spending to balance the budget. As a result, the Depression returned in 1938. For more, see Timeline of the Great Depression.
In 1939, Hitler invaded Poland. FDR started gearing up to enter the war. He began the draft in 1940. In 1941, Japan attacked Pearl Harbor. FDR increased the defense budget, adding $209 billion to the debt to pay for World War II. By 1945, Roosevelt had added $236 billion to the debt, a 1,048 percent increase over the $23 billion debt at the end of Hoover's last budget, fiscal year 1933.That was the largest increase of any president percentage-wise.
Harry Truman (1945-1953)
Harry Truman took America from isolationism to global leadership. He took office on April 12, 1945, because FDR died. Germany surrendered on May 8. Japan surrendered on Aug. 14, 1945, ending World War II.
Many felt Truman forced Japan's surrender when he dropped atom bombs on Hiroshima (August 6) and Nagasaki (August 9). Others felt the bombing was unnecessary, since Japan was ready to surrender. The Air Force had bombed Tokyo and most other major industrial cities. The Navy had blockaded Japan's imports of oil and other vital materials. Truman's Chief of Staff, William Leahy, wrote, "By the beginning of September, Japan was almost completely defeated through a practically complete sea and air blockade." But Truman felt the atom bomb was absolutely necessary.
In 1947, he outlined The Truman Doctrine to contain the threat of communism. He pledged the United States to assist any democracy attacked by authoritarian forces. The Doctrine shifted U.S. foreign policy from isolationist to global policeman.
He vetoed the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947, which would have weakened unions. It also required union leaders to swear they were not communists. It allowed the president to stop strikes if they endangered national safety.
In 1947, Truman supported Secretary of State George Marshall's plan to rebuild Europe. The Marshall Plan pledged $12 billion in food, machinery and foreign direct investment. The 1947 National Security Act consolidated the Army and Navy into the Defense Department. It created the Air Force, the National Security Council and the CIA.
In 1948, Truman airlifted food and fuel in West Berlin after the Soviets blockaded the city between June 24, 1948 and May 12, 1949. He recognized the country of Israel after it declared statehood in May 1948. He said it was a matter of justice for the Jewish people.
Truman outlined the Fair Deal on January 5, 1949. It called for national health insurance and raising the minimum wage. It also proposed the Fair Employment Practices Act to make illegal any religious and racial discrimination in hiring. Congress rejected national health insurance, but passed the rest of the Fair Deal.
North Korea invaded South Korea in June 1950. General MacArthur led the UN forces that pushed North Korea back to the 38th parallel. That border held when the ceasefire was negotiated in 1953. (Source: "What Is Truman's Most Lasting Legacy," Examiner, February 6, 2010.)
Truman decided not to run for a third term, even though he could have. The Twenty-Second Amendment of 1950 limited presidents to two terms but did not apply to him.
The Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952 continued quotas for immigrants based upon country of origin. It allowed Asians to immigrate after the War. It prioritized family reunification and desired skills. Truman vetoed the Act because it had lower quotas for Asians, which he felt was discriminatory. But the Act passed anyway.
Truman added $7 billion, a 3 percent increase from the $259 billion debt at the end of FDR’s last budget, FY 1945.
John F. Kennedy directed federal agencies to accelerate their budgeted spending to end the 1960 recession. He created a food stamp program and expanded United States Employment Service. He increased the minimum wage, improved Social Security benefits and passed an urban renewal package. JFK asked the Federal Reserve to keep interest rates low by using its open market operations to buy U.S. Treasury notes. (Source: “John F. Kennedy,” About.com Guide to American History.)
In December 1962, he proposed additional education and research spending. He suggested cutting the income tax rate from 91 percent to 65 percent. He endorsed deficit spending until businesses began hiring again. (Sources: "Address to the Economic Club of New York," JFK Presidential Library and Museum, December 14, 1962. "The Myth of JFK as a Supply-Side Tax Cutter," U.S. News, January 26, 2011.)
Kennedy's primary military concern was preventing the expansion of communism. In February 1961, he authorized the Bay of Pigs invasion to overthrow the communist leader Fidel Castro. In June 1961, he met with Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev, who threatened to cut off U.S. access to Berlin. JFK increased military spending by adding intercontinental ballistic missile forces. On August 13, 1961, the Soviets erected the Berlin Wall.
In October 1962, Kennedy blockaded Cuba after finding out that the Soviets were building nuclear missile sites. The USSR removed the sites. For more, see Cuban Missile Crisis. In 1963 JFK increased U.S. military advisers in Vietnam to more than 16,000. That gave U.S. support to the November 1963 military coup. (Source: "Vietnam," JFK Presidential Library.)
On October 24, 1963, Kennedy signed the Maternal and Child Health and Mental Retardation Planning Amendment to the Social Security Act. It provide funding to states to improve their programs. On October 31, 1963, he signed the Mental Retardation Facilities and Community Mental Health Centers Construction Act. It funded community mental health centers to provide better care than mental hospitals. For the consequences, see Deinstitutionalization.
Kennedy added $23 billion to the national debt, an 8 percent increase from the $289 billion debt at the end of Eisenhower's last budget, FY 1961. His deficit spending ended the recession and contributed to an expansion that lasted until 1970.
Lyndon Johnson was sworn in on November 22, 1963, two hours after John F. Kennedy was assassinated. After completing the final year of JFK's term, he was elected in 1964 with 61 percent of the votes. This electoral mandate allowed him to expand the federal government's role and avoid any recessions. The Federal Reserve had to resort to contractionary monetary policy to cool growth and prevent inflation.
LBJ created Medicare, Medicaid and urban renewal initiatives. He also championed equal rights for all to vote, ride buses and go to school. You also have him to thank for the Vietnam War, which he escalated but could not win.
LBJ declared a War on Poverty to push through passage of Kennedy's tax cut and civil rights bill. For young African Americans, the unemployment rate was 25 percent. The number of children on welfare had doubled between 1950 and 1960, to 2.4 million.
In 1964, LBJ created the Great Society. It changed the definition of the American Dream from one of opportunity to one that guaranteed wellbeing. It increased spending on education and health care. Medicare covered hospitalization for seniors and Medicaid provided health care for those living below the poverty level. It created the National Endowment for the Arts, Public Broadcasting Services, and drivers’ education. LBJ created new programs to address crime and delinquency, as well as beautification and conservation.
The Department of Housing and Urban Development built public housing and redeveloped slums.
In 1965, LBJ sent 100,000 combat troops to Vietnam. By 1968, he increased the defense budget to support 500,000 troops. The increased government spending added $42 billion, or 13 percent, to the national debt.
Jimmy Carter (1977-1981)
Jimmy Carter's presidency was overshadowed by the stagflation created by Richard Nixon. Stagflation combines economic contraction with double-digit inflation. Carter worked hard to combat the continuing economic woes of inflation and unemployment. He added eight million jobs but could not combat the effects of double-digit inflation and the Fed's misguided efforts to end it.
Carter created the Department of Education and bolstered Social Security. He established a national energy policy that deregulated oil prices to spur domestic production. He also deregulated the trucking and airlines industries. He expanded the national park system.
In 2002, he received the Nobel Peace Prize for his work in the 1978 Camp David Accord. He established full diplomatic relations with China and negotiated the SALT II nuclear limitation treaty with the Soviets.
On November 4, 1979, Iranian students took 66 Americans hostage at the U.S. Embassy in Tehran. Although Carter's administration negotiated a release in December 1981, it was too late to save Carter's presidency.
Bill Clinton is the most admired president of the past 25 years. That's because his economic policies fostered a decade of prosperity. He added 22 million new jobs, more than any other president. Home ownership was 67.7 percent, the highest rate ever recorded. The poverty rate dropped to 11.8 percent.
He signed the North American Free Trade Agreement. NAFTA boosted growth by eliminating tariffs between the United States, Canada and Mexico.
Clinton created a $63 billion budget surplus, which subtracted from the debt. He did this with the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993. It raised taxes on the wealthy. He also cut spending by reforming welfare.
Clinton did not achieve health care reform. But he did get HIPAA and CHIP passed. HIPAA permits workers to keep their company-sponsored health insurance plan after being laid off. CHIP subsidizes health insurance for children in families that earn too much to qualify for Medicaid.
Barack Obama entered office during the 2008 financial crisis. He fought it with the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. This economic stimulus package added $787 billion to the debt by cutting taxes, extending unemployment benefits and funding public works projects.
He bailed out the U.S. auto industry on March 30, 2009. That saved one million jobs and forced the companies to become more fuel efficient.
On October 9, 2009, Obama won the Nobel Peace Prize for his work in international diplomacy.
On March 23, 2010, Obama signed the Affordable Care Act. It required everyone to have health insurance or pay a tax. That provided a steady stream of premiums from enough healthy people to pay for the millions of people with pre-existing conditions who were no longer denied insurance. Obamacare expanded Medicaid. That allowed more people to get preventive care instead of using hospital emergency rooms as their primary care physicians. As a result, it slowed the rise of health care costs.
In July 2010, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act improved regulation of eight areas that led to the financial crisis. The Consumer Financial Protection Agency reduced harmful practices of credit cards and mortgages. The Financial Stability Oversight Council regulated hedge funds and banks that became too big to fail. The "Volcker Rule" banned banks from risking losses with their depositors' money. Dodd-Frank directed the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to regulate derivatives.
His administration continued battling the Tea Party Republicans after they gained Congressional majority in the 2010 mid-term elections. In December 2010, the Obama tax cuts added $858 billion to the debt in two years.
On May 1, 2011, Navy SEALs eliminated Osama bin Laden, the leader of the 9/11 attacks. Later that year, Obama ended the Iraq War. Three years later, he sent troops back under renewed threats from the Islamic State. For more, see Will It Ever End? How the Sunni-Shiite Split Affects the U.S. Economy.
In 2014, Obama wound down the war in Afghanistan. Ending the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan should have reduced annual military spending. Instead, it became the largest discretionary budget item and one of the leading causes of the budget deficit and national debt. At over $800 billion, it was higher than during the Bush Administration. For more, see War on Terror Costs.
In 2015, Obama brokered a nuclear peace agreement with Iran. Later that year, Obama's team negotiated the Trans-Pacific Partnership. He launched the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership between the United States and the European Union.
Obama announced carbon reduction regulations in 2014. He enacted the Clean Power Plan in 2015. It should reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 32 percent from 2005 levels by 2030. It does this by setting carbon reduction goals for the nation's power plants.
Obama created more jobs than Clinton, if you count the 22.3 million people put to work from the depths of the recession in January 2010 to the end of his term.
Obama increased the national debt by $7.917 trillion, a 68 percent increase from the $11.657 trillion debt at the end of George W. Bush’s last budget, FY 2009. For more, see How Much Has Obama Added to the Debt.
As a result of the recession and stimulus spending, the national debt grew the most dollar-wise during President Obama's two terms. He added $7.917 trillion, a 68 percent increase, in seven years. This was the fifth-largest increase percentage-wise. Federal income was down, thanks to lower tax receipts from the 2008 financial crisis. The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act was designed to reduce the debt by $143 billion over ten years. But these savings didn't show up until the later years.
For more, see National Debt Under Obama.