3 Ways to Decide How Much to Save for College
Choose the Right Goal for You, Then Get Started
When it comes to paying for college, the earlier you begin, the better. But getting started can be overwhelming. The price of college is rising—the cost of college has grown faster than than the overall basket of goods and services that people generally buy since 1980—and there’s a host of other unknowns to plan for. Should you choose a public or private university? Should you stay in-state or go out of state? Could your child get scholarships? What about grad school?
Luckily, you don’t need to know the answers to all these questions to start saving. Here are a few of the most helpful strategies for deciding how much to save for college.
Choose an End Goal
One of the most common ways to set a savings goal is based on the projected cost of college. It helps to start by using one of the calculators out there to help you estimate the cost of college for your child, based on factors like your child’s age, the type of school you expect your child to attend, and the expected rise in the cost of college. You should also consider whether there is a specific school that you already know your child wants to attend.
Getting a little sticker shock? The good news is that whether you’re saving for in-state, out-of-state, or private, you don’t have to plan for the whole amount.
Many financial advisors instead recommend saving about one-third of the cost of college, with the expectation that the rest will come from financial aid, scholarships, and current parent and/or student income. This can make the goal of saving for college feel more realistic and achievable.
For example, let's that you just had a child and you’re ready to start saving now. In order to pay a third of the projected cost of college, your end goal might be $73,700 for a public in-state university, $116,800 for a public, out-of-state school, and $145,100 for a private college.
Set the Right Monthly Goal
Is it a little too difficult to imagine the end goal, years from now? Consider walking it back to a monthly contribution amount. Just remember that how you save will make a big impact on how much you save by the time your child starts college.
Many experts recommend using a 529 college savings plan, a tax-advantaged investment account. A 529 plan offers tax-free growth and withdrawals for qualified higher education expenses, which include tuition and fees, room and board, books, computers, and special education expenses.
What does this mean for you? Choosing a 529 plan could mean a much lower monthly contribution since the money grows over time. With a 529 plan, solid monthly contribution amounts for a child born in 2017 would be about $165 for a public in-state school, $260 for public out-of-state, or $325 for a private university.
If you intend to save using a traditional savings account or a taxed investment account, you’ll want to adjust your monthly contribution accordingly. For example, the average interest rate on savings accounts as of June 2020 was 0.06% APY (annual percentage yield).
At that rate, in a savings account, you’d need to contribute about $300 per month for 18 years to pay for a third of the projected cost of a public, in-state college; around $500 for out-of-state; and around $600 per month for a private university. Nearly double the required savings compared to a 529.
Using a taxed investment account can yield significantly better returns on your savings. With an average 7% return, a monthly contribution of about $190 would cover the projected cost of a public in-state university, $300 for out-of-state, or $390 for a private college. However, you will miss out on the 529 plan’s tax exemptions on dividends and gains.
Decide Based on What You Can Afford
Lastly, you can set a monthly savings goal for college based on what your family can afford. This is a good approach if there’s not much wiggle room in your budget.
Of course, what’s affordable will vary widely from one family to the next. If you’re not sure what’s doable for your family, try breaking it down using the Lumina Foundation’s Rule of 10 formula.
Though originally intended as a benchmark for colleges seeking to expand access to higher education, the formula can certainly be utilized by families. This approach recommends that families pay for college using the benchmarks:
- Families save 10% of their discretionary income;
- Families save over a period of 10 years; and
- Students work 10 hours per week while attending college.
Discretionary income is typically defined as total after-tax income, minus all minimal survival expenses such as food, medicine, housing, utilities, insurance, transportation, and so on.
The Lumina Foundation states that for the purposes of these benchmarks, any income above 200% of the federal poverty level is “discretionary.” For a family of four in 2020, that would be any income over $52,400.
Following this formula, a family making an average of $100,000 annually might save 10% of the remaining $47,600, or $397 per month. Over 10 years, that’s nearly $48,000 saved for college. With a student working 10 hours per week for 50 weeks per year at the current $7.25 minimum wage, that’s an additional $3,625, for a total contribution of $14,500 over four years.
Of course, if your income increases or decreases, your contributions can be adjusted accordingly. And you can always make this methodology go farther by using a tax-advantaged savings tool to grow your money over time.
For example, if a family with an 8-year-old child began saving $397 per month in a 529 savings plan, that amount would grow to be enough to cover the third of costs that experts recommend for a public-out-of-state school, or about half the cost of an in-state university.
While it’s easy to get sticker shock from skyrocketing college costs, remember that the amount you need to save is likely much lower.
The important thing is to start as early as possible and to be consistent with saving. However, if your child is older, don’t panic—you can still save a significant amount in a shorter time frame.
Financial aid, scholarships, student work, your income while your child is attending college, and contributions from family can all help to make up the rest.
Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. "The Rise and Fall of College Tuition Inflation," Page 57. Accessed June 22, 2020.
Cappex. "The Most Common College Savings Mistakes." Accessed June 22, 2020.
FINRA. "529 Savings Plans." Accessed June 22, 2020.
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. "Weekly National Rates and Rate Caps - Weekly Update." Accessed June 22, 2020.
Lumina Foundation. "A Benchmark for Making College Affordable," Page 5-6. Accessed June 22, 2020.
Lumina Foundation. "A Benchmark for Making College Affordable," Page 7-8 Accessed June 22, 2020.
Office of The Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation. "Poverty Guidelines." Accessed June 22, 2020.