Should You Get a Balance Transfer or a Debt Consolidation Loan?

Learn the pros and cons of these solutions for reducing debt

Young Woman doing Research Online
••• Yuri_Arcurs / Getty Images

Paying off debt is never easy. But securing a lower interest rate or smaller payments can help make your payments more affordable, which can help you become debt-free faster.

When it comes to common consumer debts like credit cards and personal loans, two of the most common ways to secure better repayment terms are balance transfers and debt consolidation loans.

Both options have unique advantages and disadvantages. You can make an educated decision about which is best for your needs if you understand the mechanics of balance transfers vs. debt consolidation loans.

Basics of Balance Transfers

With a balance transfer, you transfer or shift one or more high-interest debts (such as a credit card or personal loan) to a credit card with a lower interest rate. To do so, find a balance transfer card that your credit score qualifies you for, read the terms of the card, and ask your card issuer to transfer the debts to a credit card. You can often do this online. You will receive a new card with the balance you transferred plus a balance transfer fee from the card issuer. You'll now only have one bill to monitor, which can simplify monthly payments.

The card may come with a low or 0% introductory annual percentage rate (APR) that lasts for six to 12 months before the standard interest rate kicks in, along with other favorable terms like no late fees or a payment due date of your choice. In some cases, the card will also come with balance transfer checks. While you can put the proceeds from these checks toward other loans (auto loans, for example), the check amounts will be added to the balance of your card at the introductory APR.

Balance transfers are most attractive when you know you will pay off transferred debt before the introductory APR expires, which would allow you to pay no interest on your debt. Eliminating interest charge not only reduces the total costs of borrowing but also keeps your loan balance from growing, as 100% of each payment will go toward reducing your debt during the no-interest period. That being said, it's critical to understand the terms of your offer.

Fees

Find out whether you’ll have to pay a fee to transfer balances. Costs are often around 3% to 5% of the amount you transfer, or a flat dollar amount, such as $20. However, a few balance transfer cards charge no fee if the transfer the balance to the new card within a certain number of days of opening the card.

You might also take on new annual fees if you open a new credit card. Any savings you get from a lower interest rate need to exceed the transfer and annual fees to make the balance transfer worthwhile.

Interest Rates

The best interest rates are available for customers with good or excellent credit. You might see tempting introductory APR offers in advertisements, but you may not qualify for them. Don't bite until you evaluate what the card issuer actually offers after reviewing your credit.

Even if you get 0% APR, the rate likely won't last. Check to see when the introductory rate expires and what standard rate applies after that period. In some cases, you'll need to pay off your balance during the introductory period to avoid deferred interest charges, which backdates the interest charges and could force you to pay interest accrued from the time you transferred the balance.

You'll generally need a credit score of 670 or higher on an 850-point scale to qualify for a balance transfer card.

Credit Impacts

Balance transfers can negatively affect your credit, albeit not permanently. Every time you apply for a new balance transfer card, lenders make a hard inquiry into your credit, which can temporarily decrease your credit score by five to 10 points. New credit makes up 10% of your credit score, so you may not want to open a balance transfer card if you recently opened several other credit accounts.

If you end up opening a credit card to transfer balances, use it to pay off rather than increase your debt. Avoid using a balance transfer card for spending, which can send you deeper into debt. Your credit utilization ratio, which is the credit in use divided by your total credit limit, accounts for 30% of your credit score. Carrying too much debt (a ratio of over 30%) may hurt your credit score.

Debt Consolidation Loan Fundamentals

In addition to using a balance transfer credit card, you can also get a debt consolidation loan, which is a new loan you take out to pay off an existing loan.

The new loan might be a personal loan, a secured loan, or a P2P loan. Whichever option you choose, a debt consolidation loan should ideally come with a lower interest rate or smaller monthly payments, which can reduce the costs of borrowing or make payments more manageable. An added benefit: Since you're combining several loans into one, you'll only have to keep track of one monthly payment.

Debt consolidation loans sometimes come with a fixed interest rate, so they make more sense than a balance transfer when the introductory period on the balance transfer card is too short. For example, a 0% APR offer for three months might not be useful if you need three years to pay down your debt.

Fees 

You may or may not pay any up-front fees for debt consolidation loans. With some loans, you’ll see obvious costs, such as processing and origination fees. With other loans, the costs will be built into the interest rate or may kick in later in the loan term. Compare several loans to find the combination of up-front fees and interest charges that benefits you the most.

If you want to maintain flexibility in terms of when you pay off the debt consolidation loan, avoid lenders that impose prepayment penalties, which may force you to pay a fee if you pay off a loan before the loan term expires.

Interest Rates

The rate you pay will depend on your credit and the type of loan you use. You'll need at least a "fair" credit score of 580 or higher, but the higher your score, the lower your interest rate will be generally.

Moreover, an unsecured loan doesn't require you to put up collateral to secure the loan, so it will generally have a higher rate than a secured loan that uses your home as collateral. This means that even with a stellar credit score, you could be approved at a higher interest rate for a personal unsecured loan than for a secured home equity loan, for example.

Interest rates for debt consolidation loans can be fixed and unchanging or variable, meaning they’ll move up and down like credit card rates. Fixed rates make it easier to plan because you’ll know what your monthly payments will be for the life of the loan. But fixed rates typically start out higher than variable rates.

You’ll probably pay interest on the loan at a rate that’s ​lower than standard credit card interest rates, but introductory rates on balance transfer cards could be even lower, at least for a limited time. Still, if you plan to pay off debt over several years—longer than any credit card promotion—you might do better with a debt consolidation loan.

Your Credit

Just like with balance transfer credit cards, new loans require hard inquiries that can impact your credit scores, at least in the short term. Over the long term, some debt consolidation loans could potentially be better for your credit than balance transfers. On the flip side, making late payments on the loan can hurt your credit score.

Credit mix, which refers to the types of credit accounts you hold, makes up 10% of your credit score. Since scores are higher when you use a mixture of different types of credit, adding loans into the mix can give your credit score a boost and make you more attractive than a borrower who relies solely on credit cards.

A debt consolidation loan can also help you reduce your debt over time, which can, in turn, reduce your credit utilization ratio and give your credit score a bump. If you make payments on time and only take on new debts you can afford, you will likely strengthen your credit with a debt consolidation loan.

Collateral

Debt consolidation loans carry additional risk: You generally have to pledge collateral for secured loans. This means that you must give the lender permission to take your assets and sell them if you fail to repay the loan. For example, you might pledge your home as part of a home equity loan, or you might use your car as collateral for an auto loan. If you fail to make payments on the loan, you could lose your home in foreclosure or have your car repossessed. There are two ways to minimize this risk:

  • Keep unsecured loans unsecured: Collateral can help you get approved, but because pledging your assets is risky, it's best to consolidate unsecured debts with an unsecured loan because the only thing at risk is your credit. If, in contrast, you take out a secured loan such as a home equity loan to pay off unsecured credit card debt, you will dramatically increase the risk of losing your home.
  • Refinance secured loans: If you already have debt that is secured by collateral, consider refinancing the loan, or replacing the loan with a completely new loan. For example, consider using a balance transfer card or a debt consolidation loan for unsecured debts, and get a different loan for your secured debts.

Consolidating Student Loans

If you have student loans, do some homework before consolidating those loans. Government loans provide unique benefits like the potential for loan forgiveness or the ability to postpone payments. If you consolidate with a private lender, you may lose access to those borrower-friendly features.

Deciding Between a Balance Transfer vs. a Debt Consolidation Loan

Both options have the effect of merging multiple debts into one, which can make payments more manageable. Provided that you secure more favorable terms from the balance transfer or loan, such as lower interest rates or smaller payments, both approaches can also make your payments more affordable.

The best choice for you depends on the terms you get, your repayment plan, and your comfort with risk. A balance transfer is preferable if you secure a 0% introductory APR and can pay off the balance before that period expires. As unsecured debt, a credit card is also low in risk—your property isn't on the line if you fail to make payments.

A debt consolidation loan may be a better option if you want to merge multiple personal loans into one monthly payment or if you plan to repay your loan over a long period of time. But if you opt for a secured loan, you risk losing your property if you can't repay the loan.

Regardless of which option you choose, minimize or avoid new debt as you pay off the balance transfer credit card or the debt consolidation loan so that you stay on track to get debt-free.

Article Sources

  1. Experian. "How a Balance Transfer Works—and Who It’s Best For." Accessed March 25, 2020.

  2. Experian. "What Happens After a Balance Transfer?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  3. Experian. "Should I Make a Balance Transfer?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  4. Experian. "Can You Pay Off One Credit Card with Another?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  5. Experian. "How Many Points Does an Inquiry Drop Your Credit Score?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  6. Experian. "What Affects Your Credit Scores?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  7. Experian. "What is a Credit Utilization Rate?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  8. Experian. "How Do Different Debt Consolidation Programs Work?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  9. Experian. "Best Loans to Consolidate Debt in 2020." Accessed March 25, 2020.

  10. Experian. "What Is Debt Consolidation?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  11. National Credit Union Administration. "Personal Loans: Secured vs. Unsecured." Accessed March 25, 2020.

  12. Experian. "Can Debt Consolidation Affect Your Credit Score?" Accessed March 25, 2020.

  13. Wells Fargo. "Student Loan Refinancing and Consolidation." Accessed March 25, 2020.

  14. Federal Student Aid Office of the U.S. Department of Education. "When It Comes to Paying for College, Career School, or Graduate School, Federal Student Loans Can Offer Several Advantages Over Private Student Loans." Accessed March 25, 2020.