Canada Economy Facts and Outlook

The Struggling Economy Is Why Justin Trudeau Is the New Prime Minister

Justin Trudeau
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau gives a speech as he attends the Official Welcome Ceremony for the Royal Tour at the British Columbia Legislature on September 24, 2016 in Victoria, Canada. Photo by Samir Hussein/WireImage/Getty Images

Canada's economic output as measured by gross domestic product was $1.67 trillion in 2016. This was just one tenth that of its primary trading partner, the United States ($18.5 trillion) and slightly less than its other NAFTA partner, Mexico ($2.3 trillion). (Source: "Canada's Economy," CIA World Factbook.)

Canada’s 2016 GDP growth rate was 1.2 percent, slower than both the United States (1.6 percent) and Mexico (2.1 percent).

Canada's standard of living, as measured by GDP per capita, was $46,200, lower than the United States ($57,300) but higher than Mexico ($18,900). (Source: CIA World Factbook.)

Canada is roughly the same size as the United States (3.8 million square miles), but only has 1/10 the people (34.6 million). It's three times the size of Mexico, with one-third the people. Why is Canada so sparsely populated? Climate. Its northern half is so cold for so much of the year that the ground remains permanently frozen. As a result, 90 percent of the people live within 100 miles of the US border.

Canada has more fresh water than any other country, with between two to three million lakes. However, most of it cannot be used for productive uses, such as hydropower or even irrigation, thanks to the cold climate. Only 4.3 percent of Canada's land is suitable for farming, compared to 16.9 percent of land in the U.S., and 12.9 percent in Mexico.

(Source: "Permafrost." The Canadian Encyclopedia. CIA World Factbook.)

Trudeau and Trump

On April 24, 2017, the Trump Administration warned it may impose a 20 percent tariff on Canadian lumber. That would affect $10 billion in exports. Western provinces allow loggers to cut trees on government-owned land.

The U.S. Commerce Department says the reduced rates allow for trade dumping.

The threat alone has reduced imports of Canadian softwood lumber. The tariff would be retroactive. Many companies hesitate to purchase lumber that could face a 20 percent surcharge.

The Commerce Department must prove to the U.S. International Trade Commission that Canada's actions injure the American lumber industry. In 2004, a NAFTA panel said the United States did not prove the dumping had harmed the American lumber industry.   (Source: “Trump Plans to Impose Tariff on Imports of Canadian Softwood,” Fox Business News, April 24, 2017.)

On April 26, 2017, President Trump signaled the United States may withdraw from NAFTA. That follows the executive order he signed on January 23, 2017. That stated is intent to renegotiate NAFTA. He argues that the current agreement gives too much away to Mexico. Canada's Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said he would be willing to negotiate a separate bilateral agreement with the United States. ​For more, see What Happens If Trump Dumps NAFTA?

Trump also withdrew the United States from the Trans-Pacific Partnership. Trudeau supports that agreement. 

Canada's Economy Depends on Exports to the United States

Canada is the 12th largest exporter in the world.

It exports $402 billion in 2016. Three-fourths of this goes to the United States. Trade with the United States and Mexico has tripled since 1994, thanks to NAFTA. Canada is America's largest supplier of energy. That includes oil, gas, uranium and electric power. (Source: CIA World Factbook.)

Canada struggles to overcome another geographic handicap. It doesn't border any countries other than the United States. This makes shipments of goods to other markets more expensive.

Canada benefited by the discovery of oil sands in Alberta. That gave it the third largest oil reserves in the world (173.1 billion barrels). It's behind Saudi Arabia and Venezuela. It ranks ninth in the world in recoverable shale oil. It's fifth in shale gas, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. Canada is now the fifth largest oil exporter.

It ships 1.576 million barrels at day, recently surpassing Mexico. (Source: "Canada Places in Top Ten," Calgary Herald.)

On the other hand, Canada's reliance on oil exports may throw it into a recession. That's because oil prices fell from $100 to $25 a barrel in 2014. Canada's central bank cut interest rates to stimulate the economy, but that may aggravate a housing bubble. The government could spend more, but the debt-to-GDP ratio is already high at 92 percent. (Source: "A Rough Ride," The Economist, July 11, 2015.)

That's why Canadians elected Justin Trudeau as the new Prime Minister. He is the son of charismatic Pierre Trudeau. His election reflects a demographic shift toward liberalism. The Liberals gained 2.8 million new voters. These are people who didn't vote in 2011 when Canada elected conservative Stephen Harper. (Source: The Daily Shot, October 22, 2015.)

Trudeau promised to spend C$60 billion in new infrastructure. This will increase the budget deficit. But that might be paid for with taxes on marijuana, which Trudeau plans to legalize. (Source "All Change?" The Economist, The World in 2016.)

Future Outlook

Trudeau also agreed to cut greenhouse gas emissions. That could reduce oil sands production. It would trigger lawsuits from companies that invested billions in development. (Source: "Cloud Hangs Over Canada's Oil Sand," The Wall Street Journal, January 25, 2016.)

Over the next forty years, global warming might benefit Canada. Between 1906 and 1982, the area of ice shelves fell 90 percent. That's because arctic winter temperatures increased 1.8 degrees Fahrenheit every ten years for the last six decades. As a result, the Northern Sea Route and the Northwest Passage may open to commercial traffic. That could compete with the Panama Canal by 2050. (Source: "Warmer Climate to Open New Arctic Shipping Routes by 2050: Study," Reuters, March 8, 2013. "Canada's Arctic Nearly Loses Entire Ice Shelf," Huffington Post, September 11, 2013.)