Things to Know Before You Buy a Short Sale House
The Wrong Short Sale House Might Not Ever Close
In the world of home buying, a short sale happens when the lender allows you to pay less than the mortgage amount that's owed by the current homeowner. While this may initially sound like a great deal, you should practice caution when entering into any short sale arrangement.
Before you get all excited over the prospect of buying that short sale house, pick up the phone and call your real estate agent. Your agent needs to research that short sale listing first.
In some real estate markets, fewer than one in 10 short sales close. Just because a home is listed as a short sale doesn't mean it's really for sale (because it's subject to lender approval), nor does it mean it will sell at the advertised price. Here are six things you need to know before trying to buy a short sale.
Comparable Sales for a Short Sale House
The short sales I list in Sacramento are all priced below comparable sales, yet they are priced in line with pending sales. Why? Because short sales take anywhere from two to four months, on average, to close, and pending sales will become the comparable sales at closing.
Some short sales are priced extremely low. So low that the sellers' bank will never accept them. These types of listings receive multiple offers. But all is not lost. It will need to be priced near market value to get your offer accepted. If you're not prepared to pay above a superficial price on a lowball short-sale listing, then pass.
Mortgage Amounts, Number of Loans, and Lenders
Ask your agent to research how much is owed against the home and find out the number of loans that are recorded. A second or third mortgage lender will receive peanuts as compared to the amount a senior lender in first position will get.
Moreover, some lenders, deserving or not, get a reputation for being difficult to work with. If your agent is an experienced short sale agent, he or she will know who these lenders are and can advise you of the difficulty you may encounter.
If your offer is 20% or 30% of the mortgaged amount, it probably won't see the light of day on the negotiator's desk.
The Short Sale Listing Agent's Track Record
A listing agent who is advertising a short sale but has never closed a short sale is a risky proposition for you. That's because it's up to the listing agent to submit the short sale package to the lender and negotiate. Your buyer's agent can't talk to the bank.
Some listing agents hire outside companies to do their job, and the results of those negotiations are often sketchy at best. Ask yourself, do you want to risk rejection of your short sale purchase because the listing agent has no experience?
Short Sale Seller Qualifications
Find out if the listing agent has received a completed short sale package from the seller, and ask about the contents of that package. A complete short sale package consists, at a minimum, of the following:
- Sellers' hardship letter
- Tax returns
- Payroll stubs
- Financial statement
- Bank statements
Some sellers do not want to cooperate and are slow to return these documents. Others have never been told by their agent that these documents are mandatory. You don't want your short sale purchase delayed because the listing agent doesn't have the required documents.
Number of Short Sale Offers Received
Homes priced under market value will receive multiple offers. An agent is not required to disclose the terms of those offers, but you do want to know how many offers you are up against.
Here's how it generally works:
- When a short sale home comes on the market, the first offer will most likely be a tad below list price.
- The second, at list price.
- The third offer will be slightly higher, maybe by $1,000 or $2,000.
- The fourth offer will be significantly more.
You want to make an offer that will beat the competition yet still be below market, or don't waste your time.
The Listing Agent's Short Sale Procedures
Although realtors are required by the Realtor Code of Ethics to treat everybody fairly, not every agent is a realtor. This means the short sale listing agent may decide to submit only one offer to the seller and withhold other offers.
Withholding other offers could be considered to be a violation of the fiduciary relationship formed between the listing agent and the seller. The seller is entitled to receive the highest and best price, including all offers. Realize that even if your offer is submitted to the bank, as time marches by while waiting for short sale approval, another buyer could outbid you. Let the seller know if you are willing to raise your price if necessary.
At the time of writing, Elizabeth Weintraub, BRE # 00697006, is a Broker-Associate at Lyon Real Estate in Sacramento, California.
National Association of Realtors. "Short Sales and Foreclosures." Accessed March 30, 2020.
National Association of Realtors. "Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice of the National Association of Realtors." Accessed March 30, 2020.