U.S. Military: Letter of Admonishment

There are several non-punitive forms of military disciplinary action

Air Force cadet on bench
Sean Murphy/The Image Bank/Getty Images

In addition to the more serious discipline tools under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, commanders and supervisors have a diverse set of administrative tools to assist them in correcting inappropriate behavior. Counseling, admonitions, reprimands, and extra training are tools that, while they derive their status and authority from the unit commander, are usually delegated down the chain to the supervisory level.

Such administrative actions are sometimes called "nonpunitive measures." The use of nonpunitive measures is encouraged and, to a degree, defined in the Manual for Court Martial, R.C.M. 306(c)(2), nonwhich states:

Administrative action. A commander may take or initiate administrative action, in addition to or instead of other action taken under this rule [e.g., NJP, court-martial], subject to regulations of the Secretary concerned. Administrative actions include corrective measures such as counseling, admonition, reprimand, exhortation, disapproval, criticism, censure, reproach, rebuke, extra military instruction, or the administrative withholding of privileges, or any combination of the above.

 

    Counseling as Military Discipline

    In the military, counseling can be formal or informal and can be verbal or in writing. Most military folks are probably counseled to one degree or other several times per day.

    When most military people think about counseling, however, they usually think about the more formal, written counseling.

    Some of the branches have pre-printed forms to document a counseling session, but many supervisors prefer to document a counseling session via a written letter. 

    While the effects of a single counseling session are not all that significant, one should be aware that counseling which documents inappropriate behavior can be used at a later time, for example in support of an administrative demotion action, administrative separation, or in justifying lowered performance evaluations.

    Admonitions and Reprimands in the Military

    The only difference between an admonition and a reprimand is the degree.  A reprimand is more severe than an admonition. As with counseling, admonitions and reprimands can be verbal or can be in writing. 

    Unlike counseling, admonitions and reprimands are censures, meaning one did something wrong. Records of admonitions and reprimands can be filed and later used to justify more serious measures, such as nonjudicial punishment actions, administrative demotions, and administrative separations.

    One should be very careful when providing a written response to counseling, admonitions, and reprimands, as any response becomes part of the written record.

    The same is true about refusing to sign receipt of counseling, admonitions, and reprimands. 

    Extra Military Instruction in the Military

    The term "extra military instruction" (EMI) is used to describe the practice of assigning extra tasks to a service member who is exhibiting behavioral or performance deficiencies for the purpose of correcting those deficiencies through the performance of the assigned tasks.

    Normally such tasks are performed in addition to normal duties. Because this kind of leadership technique is more severe than non-punitive censure, the law has placed some significant restraints on the commander's discretion in this area.

    The authority to assign EMI to be performed during working hours is not limited to any particular rank or rate but is an inherent part of the authority vested in officers, NCOs, and petty officers. The authority to assign EMI to be performed after working hours rests in the commanding officer or officer in charge but may be delegated to officers, petty officers, and noncommissioned officers.